Site
created 12/15/97. |
|
review
added: 4/7/03
Bob
Dylan: Blonde on Blonde
1966
(1999) - Columbia Records
review
by Grey Cavitt of MusicTAP
|
Album
Rating: A+
Audio Ratings (SACD 2.0): A-
Extras Rating: N/A
Specs and Features
73 mins, single-sided, single-layered, jewel case packaging, liner
notes booklet, track access (14 tracks - see
track listing below), audio formats: SACD DSD 2.0
|
Stereo
Mix Produced by: Bob Johnston
Re-mixed by: Vic Anasini
Mastered by: Stephen Saper
Bob Dylan (vocals/guitar/harmonica/piano), Charlie McCoy
(bass/guitar/trumpet/harmonica), Wayne Moss (guitar/vocals), Kenneth
A Buttrey (drums), Hargus Robbins (piano/keyboards), Jerry Kennedy
(guitar), Joe South (Guitar), Al Kooper ( various), Bill Aikins
(keyboards), Henry Strzelecki (bass), Jaime (Robbie) Robertson
(various)
|
Highway
61 Revisited melded Dylan's mighty folk with blues and
rock to create a new music. On Blonde on
Blonde, Dylan drives his experiments even farther,
proving that no musical style exists that cannot be grafted onto a
well-written song. This album is simply breathtaking. He tackles so
much, but he achieves even more. Each song becomes a journey into
narcotic landscapes, another world where the terrain constantly
shifts, one's footing is none too certain, and the slightest word
can mean everything. Spewing such brilliant songs over two albums,
Dylan especially shocks with the coherent nature of the work. Even
if he rockets one around a strange world, the journey is still one
united, wild trip that never seems disjointed or diffuse. Visions
of Johanna sounds like a murky yet revelatory sad dream,
and Just Like a Woman is
drenched in loss and regret. How an artist can sound both this
adventurous and in control at once is one of the many mysteries and
enchantments of this unique, ground-shattering album.
Dylan's musical trek is much smoother than Blonde
on Blonde's transfer through several different versions
and formats over the last thirty-five years. On the way to this
Super Audio Compact Disc release, Blonde has been through more than
one mono vinyl version and several vinyl stereo mixes. In the
digital age it has emerged in a couple of crassly edited CDs, a
standard CD with the correct running time but dull sound, and a
MasterSound Gold CD version that tweaked the music much too far into
the trebly regions of bass-less shrillness. Finally, this
masterpiece arrives as an SACD, and delightfully, it has seldom
sounded better.
This Blonde on Blonde is a
remix, as the original stereo master tapes are reportedly over worn.
Rather than second-guessing the artist and original engineers with a
new, more modern sounding mix, the remixers (just who they are is a
matter of great dispute) painstakingly strove to recreate the
standard vinyl mix with careful, studied detail. This is a wise move
when recreating an acknowledged masterpiece such as this, and the
decision strengthens this new release.
Immediately, Rainy Day Women # 12 &
35 highlights the sonic excellence of this SACD. The
instrumental separation is startling, and the clarity and detail the
format's increased resolution offers is breathtaking. From the drum
announcing the first song, softly mushy but clear and powerful, to
the acid-scorched wired guitars of Leopard
Skin Pill-Box Hat and Obviously
5 Believers, this music impresses with an in-the-room
quality most audiophiles live for. Throughout the album, the
harmonica leaps out with a definition and presence that shreds,
whines, and soothes, and the piano approaches the depth the ivories
plunk out on the vinyl versions. The cymbals magnificently sound
rather than simply sizzle, and the bass and midrange bounce out from
whatever pits the former MasterSound disc thrust them. Listen to how
the descending bass after the chorus of Stuck
Inside of Mobile with the Memphis Blues Again smoothly
and powerfully blossoms without blooming into over-booming. Still,
while the mix brings out each instrument and the SACD faithfully and
sharply reproduces it, these sounds can swirl into an intertangled
musical swell such as in the chorus of One
of Us Must Know.
The mix is also wonderfully dynamic. Unlike so many modern
remasters, here quiet instruments linger behind the others while
louder strains take center stage. A great example is the organ in
Temporary like Achilles; it
leaps and ducks throughout the musical maze, now nearly dominant,
now barely audible. SACD has an incredible dynamic capacity and Blonde
on Blonde luckily takes full advantage of it.
The major drawback is an occasional lack of air and space between
those well-separated strings, skins, and horns jumping out of the
opposite speakers. Perhaps it is partly a result of a tad too much
brightness in the upper range; though not shrill as the gold disc,
this is still rather hot. Perhaps the age of the tapes are to blame.
Perhaps only the mastering engineers know the reason. Whatever the
cause, Visions of Johanna, for
example, simply does not have the smoky yet real sense of atmosphere
between the players that the standard vinyl had.
The minor drawback here is that this wonderfully mixed SACD is not
a hybrid. No SACD player in your car, no new Blonde
on Blonde in your car.
Still, when the final two tracks play with such revelatory wonder,
it is hard to complain. Obviously 5
Believers is a humming, strumming, squelching glory never
quite captured on previous digital releases, and Sad
Eyed Lady of the Lowlands is fresh and freed from the
dingy film it has been trapped under since its move from record to
CD.
Blonde on Blonde has always
been an essential rock album. Now, it is also a necessary SACD.
Here's hoping the release of 15 Dylan albums in the format this fall
imitates this excellent example of instrumental clarity and detail,
faithfulness to the original mixes, and dynamic range. Dylan
definitely deserves no less.
Grey Cavitt
gcavitt@musictap.net
Track Listing:
Rainy Day Women #12 & 35
Pledging My Time
Visions of Johanna
One of Us Must Know (Sooner or Later)
I Want You
Stuck Inside of Mobile with the Memphis Blues Again
Leopard-Skin Pill-Box Hat
Just Like a Woman
Most Likely You Go Your Way and I'll Go Mine
Temporary like Achilles
Absolutely Sweet Marie
4th Time Around
Obviously 5 Believers
Sad Eyed Lady of the Lowlands |
|
|