Site
created 12/15/97. |
page
added: 12/5/06
The
Spin Sheet
DVD
reviews by Bill Hunt of The Digital Bits
|
Cars
Widescreen - 2006
(2006) - Pixar (Disney)
Film Rating: B
Disc Ratings (Video/Audio/Extras): A/A/B-
Cars tells the story of
Lightning McQueen (voiced by Owen Wilson), a rookie race car
who's hot in the running for the coveted Piston Cup at the
Dinoco 400. But when McQueen finishes the 400 in a three-way tie
with a pair of veteran racers, it's determined that the Piston
Cup will be decided by a tie-breaker race in California. While
on his way there, however, McQueen gets lost in the desert and
soon finds himself stuck in the tiny, Route 66 town of Radiator
Springs. There, he meets a number of new four-wheeled friends,
including Sally (Bonnie Hunt), Mater (Larry the Cable Guy), Doc
Hudson (Paul Newman, in a nifty audio cameo that recalls his
work in the 1968 film Winning)
and others, who teach him that what's truly important in life
isn't speeding to your destination, but the adventures you have
along the way.
I'll have to admit right off the bat that I wasn't all that
excited about this film when I first saw the previews. Despite
the fact that watching NASCAR in high-def has become a serious
guilty pleasure for me lately, the trailers for Cars
had me thinking that Pixar was in danger of jumping the shark
into Thomas & Friends
and Jay Jay the Jet Plane
territory.
|
|
I
eventually skipped this film when it first appeared in theaters,
despite largely positive critical reviews. Thankfully, it's for just
these kinds of situations that I'm grateful for DVD, because having
finally seen this film... well, I was quite pleasantly surprised. To
be fair, Cars starts out
rather slow. In fact, I almost fell asleep in its first 30 minutes.
But once the story gets going, and the film moves off the race track
and onto Route 66... it becomes a surprisingly charming and even
heartwarming tale. I particularly enjoyed a number of in-joke
references to previous Pixar films (be sure to watch for a
lightening quick cameo by the chirping cast of For
the Birds). And it's awfully hard not to laugh at those
little tiny VW bugs.
The video on Pixar and Disney's DVD release is anamorphic
widescreen and it looks wonderful (full frame is also available, but
avoid it at all costs). Color saturation, contrast and overall image
detail are superb - so good in fact that watching this made me
wonder how much better the film might look on Blu-ray Disc (and
shame on Disney for not releasing one). You'll see a little bit of
digital compression artifacting in the crowd shots during the racing
scenes, but that's to be expected. This aside, you're going to enjoy
a great video experience even on very large projection screens. The
audio is presented in both Dolby Digital 2.0 Surround and 5.1. The
disc defaults to the 2.0 track automatically, so make sure to change
it before you start watching the film. The 5.1 mix is highly active
and atmospheric, with a big, wide soundstage and excellent bass
reinforcement.
Unfortunately, this isn't one of Pixar's loaded two-disc special
editions, which should probably be a clue that a more elaborate DVD
will be released at a later date. Still, if the extras here aren't
plentiful, they're all pretty fun. In addition to the film itself,
you get a pair of shorter animated films (Mater
and the Ghostlight and One Man
Band), the film's "epilogue" sequence without
credits, four deleted scenes (mostly presented in storyboard format,
with introduction by director John Lassiter) and a 16-minute
featurette on the making of the film. This featurette in particular
is well worth a look, as it features appearances by many of the
folks who worked on the film, including the late Joe Ranft
(Lassiter's co-director, who was sadly - and a bit ironically -
killed in a car accident during the production), as they travel down
the real Route 66 for inspiration in making the film. There's also a
sneak peek of Pixar's forthcoming Ratatouille
and other Disney DVD releases, as well as a rather disingenuous
promo for Disney Blu-ray Disc (disingenuous, because it claims that
many of the classic Disney Platinum animated films are "Coming
to Disney Blu-ray!" Sure they are... eventually. But not
anytime soon based on what I've been told. Maybe you'll see one or
two by the end of 2007. Maybe.). There's even a cute animated Easter
egg - a spoof of Pixar's Boundin'
short done Cars style. Just
wait for the 'Dinoco 400' logo to appear on the Main Menu, then
navigate right to highlight it with your remote (and hit Enter).
Best of all, on the widescreen version at least, all of these extras
are anamorphic - greatly appreciated.
Cars is far from Pixar's best
film, but it's still a significant cut above the recent CG animated
fare of other studios. Fox Animation and DreamWorks Animation still
have along way to go before they're in Pixar's league. Cars
is good fun for the whole family. By the way, those of you with
young children might want to scratch-proof your DVDs with one of
those protective spray on coatings you can buy these days, because
trust me... the discs are going to get a LOT of spin time.
|
|
Battlestar
Galactica
Season 2.5 - 2006
(2006) - Sci-Fi Channel (Universal)
Program Rating: A
Disc Ratings (Video/Audio/Extras): B+/B/B-
How in the hell does this show keep getting better and better?
I don't really know, but the good news is that Battlestar
Galactica continues to be the most original,
well-told and innovative dramatic series on TV.
Season 2.5 picks right up
where the previous Season 2.0
(reviewed
here)
left off. Scratch that - it actually starts a little farther
back, by including an extended version of the mid-season finale,
Pegasus (the original
broadcast version was included on the 2.0
DVD release). The added footage gives additional depth to the
narrative, in particularly enabling you to better empathize with
Admiral Cain, and to understand exactly why she does the things
she does. The second half of Battlestar's
sophomore season unfolds on the remainder of this three-disc
set, as the surviving members of the Human race continue to flee
through space from the Cylon forces bent on their destruction.
|
|
Standout
episodes include the Resurrection
two-parter (in which the crews of the Galactica and Pegasus attempt
to destroy a key Cylon asset, while secretly plotting against one
another), Scar (in which the
fleet's Viper pilots are tested by a seemingly invincible Cylon
Raider, which picks them off one by one), The
Captain's Hand (in which Apollo suddenly finds himself
with responsibilities he never imagined) and the shocking two-part
season finale, Lay Down Your Burdens
(which changed much about this series in sudden and unexpected
ways).
All eleven episodes that make up the back half of the second season
are included here on three discs, and all are presented in excellent
quality anamorphic widescreen video. Colors, contrast and image
detail are all first-rate, with very little compression artifacting
or other visible defects. If you've seen the previous Galactica
DVDs, you'll know exactly what to expect. Audio is a good Dolby
Digital 5.1 mix, that's more immersive and atmospheric than actively
dynamic. It matches the visuals well.
As with the previous DVDs, you get all of producer Ron Moore's
podcast commentaries from Sci-Fi.com. There's also a new commentary
on the extended version of Pegasus
with Moore and producer David Eick. You get seven video featurettes,
also seen on Sci-Fi.com as Eick's video blogs. Deleted and extended
scenes are included too - some twenty-seven in all on the various
discs, from Resurrection Ship, Part I,
Black Market, Scar,
Sacrifice, The
Captain's Hand, Downloaded
and Lay Down Your Burdens, Parts I and II.
Finally, you get all of Moore and Eick's goofy animated production
company logos (seen on the end of each of the episodes as
broadcast). I really couldn't care less about these, but I suppose
there are fans who do.
A bonus disc was available exclusively at Best Buy stores with this
set for a limited time, that included The
Story So Far recap episode. Unfortunately, it's not in
anamorphic widescreen as it claims to be on the disc's label - it's
letterbox widescreen only.
A lot of readers have asked whether or not Universal plans to
release both Season 2.0 and
Season 2.5 as a "complete
second season" box set at some point. I suspect they may bundle
both sets together as a 2-pack eventually, and we've heard that a
high-definition HD-DVD release is on the way as well. The idea in
releasing the season in two parts on DVD was not so much to break
the budgets of fans, as to allow people to catch up with the show
during the broadcast breaks (specifically, the mid-season hiatus in
the second season and also the months prior to the start of the
third season). Still, I understand how the split releases are
irritating to some of you.
Battlestar Galactica was
recognized earlier this year with a rare honor - a prestigious
Peabody Award, given in recognition of outstanding achievements in
broadcasting. If you give the series a chance, I think you'll
quickly understand why. Forget the "sci-fi" factor: TV
drama just doesn't get much better than this. Highly recommended.
|
|
Ark
II: The Complete Series
1976 (2006) - Filmation/CBS (BCI Eclipse)
Program Rating: C-
Disc Ratings (Video/Audio/Extras): C/C/A
It's the 25th century, and Earth's gone to hell in a
hand-basket. Civilization has collapsed into anarchy, the
environment's crapped out and life is a constant struggle for
survival. Never fear though... a group of scientists have built
a futuristic truck loaded with all the latest technology to roam
around the country and bring the light of... ahem...
'enlightenment' to the masses, protect the rights of others and
restore hope for the future. Think it as the ultimate rolling
lyceum.
Ark II is another Saturday
morning show I enjoyed as a kid. Anything having to do with
space travel or the future, you could count me in. I'll be the
first to admit, however, that the series hasn't aged well.
Imagine a group of tree-hugging hippies (each card carrying
members of some future ACLU), wearing all the latest 1970s
fashions, flying around in jet packs and telling everyone that
science can save the day.
|
|
There's
a white guy with a hip Dan Haggerty beard, his hot Asian babe, a
Latino kid and a talking monkey, all cruising around and
cohabitating in a pimped out RV. Oh, and they've all got Biblical
names... even the monkey. Yeah, I don't imagine that
neo-conservatives or the religious right would approve of much of
this. It'd be pretty subversive stuff for Saturday morning fare
circa 2006 (which isn't really even geared toward kids these days
anyway).
BCI's DVD release includes all fifteen episodes of the series on
four discs. The video quality isn't stellar. Like many shows of the
period, it was shot on film. I suspect the masters were stored on
analog tape, however. Either way, this isn't reference material.
Contrast, color and image detail all suffer here, and there's
abundant digital compression artifacting. Still, the show looks
better than I've ever seen it before, so you have to keep it in
perspective. Maybe BCI could have spent a lot of money to remaster
it all, but hey... it's Ark II.
It's not exactly high on the profit return scale. The audio is Dolby
Digital 2.0 mono, also nothing special but it's fine for what it is.
You'll laugh at all the reused Star Trek
sound effects.
I'm always impressed at much effort BCI puts into the extras on
their vintage Saturday morning DVDs. Ark
II is no exception. First up, you get a couple of audio
commentary tracks with producers, writers and one of the stars
(hosted by DVD producer Andy Mangels, so as to keep the discussion
moving along nicely). Then you get a half-hour documentary on the
making of the series, complete with interviews with many of those
involved. Can that be right? Hang on... let me double check. Yeah,
there's really a half-hour documentary on the making of Ark
II on here. Wow. And it's surprisingly worth watching too
(my favorite part - learning that the monkey was actually a vicious
little bastard to work with). Moving on, you get galleries of
promotional photos, behind-the-scenes photos and even a look at
concept art for a proposed animated series. Can you imagine? On top
of that, if you pop the last disc in your PC or Mac DVD-Rom drive,
you get PDF files of the scripts for ALL fifteen episodes, as well
as the original series bible. Finally, you get a booklet that lists
the episodes and extras, and even offers bits of trivia. Sure, these
extras don't really stack up with, say, a recent Criterion release,
but come on! That's a helluva great batch of material for a show
like this. If you're a fan of Ark II,
there's not much more here that you could possibly want short of one
of those nifty jetpacks (which, by the way, can only fly for about
60 seconds in reality - not exactly the future of air travel).
Ark II is about as cheesy a
classic Saturday morning live action TV series as they come. But
it's still campy good fun. And if it looks a little (okay, a LOT
dated), well... it WAS the 1970s, right? It's no Quark,
Salvage 1 or Supertrain,
but Ark II on DVD sure as hell
puts a smile on my face. Hippies or not, those kids sure knew how to
roll. You've gotta love their wheels. I wonder what kind of gas
mileage they got, anyway?
Bill Hunt
billhunt@thedigitalbits.com |
|
|