Site
created 12/15/97. |
|
review
added: 10/29/03
Battlestar
Galactica:
The Complete Epic Series
1978
(2003) - Universal
review
by Jeff Kleist of The Digital Bits
|
Program
Rating: B+
Disc Ratings (Video/Audio/Extras): B/C/B+
Specs and Features
Approx. 1167 mins (24 episodes at 45-50 mins each, some in
multi-hour telefilm format), NR, full frame (1.33:1), 4 DVD-14 discs
(dual-sided - 1 side dual-layered, 1 side single-layered) and 2
DVD-9 discs (single-sided, dual-layered), Digipak packaging in
custom "Cylon Helmet" outer box (with lenticular eye),
audio commentary on Saga of a Star World
(with actors Richard Hatch, Dirk Benedict and Herbert Jefferson
Jr.), deleted scenes and alternate takes for each episode except
The Magnificent Warriors and
Take the Celestra (more than 3
hours in all), 5 documentaries (Remembering
Battlestar Galactica - 45 mins, The
Creation of Battlestar Galactica - 7 mins, Composing
the Score - 6 mins, The Cylons
- 5 mins, and Working with the Daggit
- 5 mins), photo gallery, Sci-Fi miniseries preview trailer,
videogame preview trailer, insert booklet with episode guide and
photos, animated program-themed menu screens with music, scene
access (6 chapters per episode - see episode guide
below), languages: English DD 5.1, subtitles: English (captions),
French and Spanish
|
For
more than five years prior to the release of Star
Wars, producer Glen Larson had been pitching his version
of "Exodus in Space". The idea was to follow a band of
Humans elsewhere in the Universe, as they fled through space in a
ragtag fleet of ships from the persecution of the vile, mechanical
Cylons. Unfortunately, the pitch held little appeal to TV networks
executives at the time. However, all that quickly changed. Following
the success of Star Wars in
1977, ABC jumped on the chance to cash in on the Sci-Fi craze.
Debuting in the fall of 1978, Battlestar
Galactica became the highest rated and biggest-hyped TV
premiere in history. Originally conceived as a series of telefilms,
ABC changed their minds, deciding instead to turn the property into
a full-fledged series literally at the last minute. The result was a
few decidedly sub-par episodes right off the bat. As with many TV
series, interest began to wane over the course of the first season
and, coupled with the long production schedule and falling ratings,
ABC cancelled the series after only 24 episodes. That left Galactica
as yet another Sci-Fi series that ended with a fan-frustrating
cliff-hanger. Thousands of letters and phone calls poured in to ABC,
but by the time the network realized their mistake, it was already
too late - the sets had been struck and the cast had moved on.
Desperation to keep the franchise alive (and perhaps the desire to
cash in on the popularity of CHiPS)
lead to a short-lived follow-up series, a monstrosity known as Galactica
1980 (which most fans would like to forget).
Like Star Trek before it,
Battlestar Galactica enjoyed a
healthy run in syndication, garnering a strong and loyal fan base.
Over time, a dozen or so videotapes of episodes were released. For
some reason however, Universal never released the best and most
popular episodes, choosing instead to show them only as badly
cobbled together telefilms designed for syndication. Until now, the
only way to see many of these episodes was in this format on TV, or
in the extraordinarily limited edition Japanese laserdisc set issued
in the 80s. Thankfully, the DVD format has changed all that. Packed
with a surprising amount of extras, and featuring appearances by
some of the greatest actors to ever grace the silver or small screen
(including Lorne Green, John Colicos, and Fred Astaire), all 24
episodes of Battlestar Galactica
can finally be enjoyed in their original, uncut format.
Battlestar Galactica was one
of the last TV shows to be finished entirely on film, which is
fortunate for fans. What this means is that instead of having to
work with blurry analog videotapes, Universal was able to pull the
original film negatives from their vault, and do brand-new, high
definition transfers of each episode. That also means that these
episodes contain scenes that haven't been seen since their original
airing on television. Shot on a television budget (albeit expensive
for the time), these episodes do exhibit quite a bit of grain and
occasional print damage, but the trade-off is that you gain
tremendous detail and texture - detail that wasn't seen even in the
original broadcasts. You can see scratches and imperfections in the
chrome of the Cylon armor, and actually make out the Vipers flying
escort, which were previously just white dots on screen. Of course,
some of the cheaper matte paintings and projected backdrops are a
little more obvious, but the benefits of these new transfers far
outweigh such issues. Fans that have been watching these episodes on
years-old VHS tapes and on the SciFi Channel will be shocked at how
much better they look on DVD.
Also benefiting greatly from today's state-of-the-art production
technology is the audio on these episodes. The producers of this set
have re-mixed every episode of this show in Dolby Digital 5.1,
working from the original audio stems. Dialogue is locked in the
center channel, but is crisp and clear despite the limited dynamic
range of the source tracks. Given that the original stems are two
decades old, you're not going to find split surrounds or panning
effects here, but you do get a ton of LFE thanks to the show having
been originally designed for Sensurround (a mono theatrical format
with an isolated LFE, faithfully reproduced on the theatrical cut
DVD).
But if the video and audio quality of this 6-disc set is
impressive, you'll be even more surprised at the supplemental
gathered for this collection. For starters, you'll find a tremendous
amount of deleted and alternate scenes for almost every single
episode. The pilot alone contains over 34 minutes of
never-before-seen footage! These are not wasted, throwaway scenes
either - this DVD collection contains virtually every single deleted
subplot fans have been talking about for 25 years. There's also
alternate takes of scenes, extended scenes, B-roll footage and even
gag reel material. In all, there's more than 3 full hours of such
material to enjoy - an absolutely incredible surprise, and more than
reason enough for fans to buy these DVDs without hesitation.
Amazingly, that's not all you get. You can also enjoy an audio
commentary track on the 3-part pilot episode, with stars Dirk
Benedict (Starbuck), Richard Hatch (Apollo) and Herb Jefferson, Jr.
(Boomer). I've seen all three together at various conventions, and
the best part of this commentary is that most of what they talk
about is new. These are stories you haven't heard before... and they
continue from the commentary into a series of documentary
featurettes. There are 4 mini documentaries in all, each under 10
minutes in length. These cover such topics as the genesis of the
show, the creation of the Daggit and the Cylons, and the composition
of the show's score. Fans have heard all the "monkey in bondage"
stories before (the Daggit was played by a chimpanzee) at
conventions, so it's the Cylon material I found most amusing.
Illustrated with plenty of B-roll of Cylons with their helmets off,
and suits of Cylon armor blowing up, the experience of being a Cylon
is well covered by the crew. The piece with Stu Philips talking
about composing the music is fairly technical, in that it
concentrates on the structure and techniques of recording for
television. Fortunately, that doesn't keep it from being
interesting.
The real documentary gem on these DVDs, however, is a 45-minute
piece called Remembering Battlestar
Galactica. It's a great retrospective look at the making
of the show, with the cast and crew free to reminisce about their
experiences. In addition to many of the featured players, this
documentary has a good concentration of supporting cast members as
well. Moments with bit players like the Borellian Nomen (and an
all-to-short bit with Patrick MacNee) are a surprising addition
here. I'll admit to a little disappointment at the absence of a few
people (like Sarah Rush, Ron Kelley and few of the other bridge crew
cast), but I'm sure the DVD producers did the best they could given
actor availability and the production budget. Rounding out this nice
batch of extras are a photo gallery, and trailer-style sneak peeks
at the new videogame and the Sci-Fi Channel's upcoming mini-series
remake.
If I had one small complaint with these DVDs, it would be the
menus. All of the discs use a common main menu that appears when you
first play them. You have to navigate into the individual episode
menus to get to what you're looking for. This is made a little
better by the welcome addition of a "play all" option that
lets you view everything on that side of the disc. You're shown each
episode in turn, and at the conclusion of it, the disc takes you
directly to the deleted scenes page. It's a very nice touch that I
wish more TV DVD sets would emulate.
Before I finish, I'd be remiss in not mentioning this set's
spectacular, though somewhat bulky, packaging. The DVDs are enclosed
in a Digipak, which fits into a large silver box featuring the face
of a Cylon staring at you. While the attempt to make the eye "move"
via a red lenticular lens didn't quite work, the effort is
appreciated. The outer box also holds a beautiful, full-color
booklet printed on semi-gloss cardstock. This booklet contains a
complete episode guide, full color photos and a smattering of
blueprints of the ships and sets from the show. Sadly, none of this
will fit on your DVD shelf, but it's a nice package nonetheless.
Battlestar Galactica was one
of my TV favorites as a child. Sure, it was derivative, and lifted
plots from previous films and TV series like Bonanza
and The Guns of Navarrone. But
anyone who complains about that is missing the entire point of Galactica.
It's got a unique spiritualism that no other program has ever
duplicated - a spiritualism that adds a distinct a sense of purpose
to the journey of these characters. The show had fantastic
production design and special effects for its day. And if all that
doesn't impress you, how can you balk at any series that features
killer robots from outer space, complete with creepy-red,
ominously-scanning eye slits? Cheesy or not, Battlestar
Galactica holds a special place in the hearts of many
Gen-Xers. I'm pleased to say that anyone who loves this show as much
as I do is going to be absolutely thrilled with the care that
Universal's taken with these DVDs.
Jeff Kleist
jeffkleist@thedigitalbits.com
EPISODE GUIDE
Disc One - Saga
of a Star World (3-hour pilot) and Lost
Planet of the Gods
Disc Two - The
Lost Warrior, The Long Patrol,
Gun on Ice Planet Zero and
The Magnificent Warriors
Disc Three - The
Young Lords, The Living Legend
and Fire in Space
Disc Four - War
of the Gods and The Man with
Nine Lives
Disc Five - Murder
on the Rising Star and Greetings
from Earth (2-hour presentation)
Disc Six - Baltar's
Escape, Experiment in Terra,
Take the Celestra and The
Hand of God |
|
|