Site
created 12/15/97. |
|
review
added: 2/21/02
Jurassic
Park III
Collector's
Edition (Widescreen) - 2001 (2001) - Amblin/Universal
(Universal)
review
by Greg Suarez of The Digital Bits
|
Film
Rating: C
Disc Ratings (Video/Extras): A/B-
Audio Ratings (DD/DTS): A-/A
Specs and Features
93 mins, PG-13, letterboxed widescreen (1.85:1), 16x9 enhanced,
single-sided, RSDL dual-layered (layer switch at 1:18:00, in chapter
17), keep case packaging, audio commentary track with special
effects team members (including Stan Winston, John Rosengrant, Dan
Taylor and Michael Lanteri), The Making
of Jurassic Park III featurette, The
New Dinosaurs of Jurassic Park III featurette,
Montana: Finding New Dinosaurs
featurette, A Visit to ILM
vignettes (including Concepts, The
Process, Muscle Simulation and Compositing),
behind-the-scenes vignettes (including A
Visit to Stan Winston Studios, Spinosaurs
Attack the Plane, Raptors Attack Udesky and
The Lake), 3
storyboard-to-feature comparisons, dinosaur turntables, production
photos, poster gallery, cast and crew bios, production notes,
Jurassic Park III soundtrack
promo, Universal Studios Theme Parks promo, Scan
Command: Jurassic Park III game promo, JP Institute
promo, DVD recommendations, Universal newsletter promo, theatrical
trailers (for Jurassic Park,
The Lost World: Jurassic Park
and Jurassic Park III),
PCFriendly DVD-ROM material (including Universal web links,
screensavers and game demos), animated film-themed menu screens with
sound effects and music, scene access (20 chapters), languages:
English (DD 5.1 & DTS 5.1), French (DD 5.1), subtitles: Spanish,
Closed Captioned |
In
1993 Jurassic Park was one of
the most visceral film-going experiences of my life. It was just as
exciting as it was mesmerizing, and I hadn't had that much fun in a
filled-to-capacity 1,000-seat auditorium since... well, probably
Ghostbusters in 1984. It
didn't hurt any that I saw JP
in one of the first DTS-equipped theaters, and I had never heard
anything quite like it before. Fast forward to 1997. After viewing
the rehash of a disaster that was The
Lost World, my enthusiasm waned, and I hoped that the
franchise would just be put to rest. When I caught wind that
Hollywood would be visiting Isles Nublar and Sorna for a third time,
I seriously felt nauseated - but I wasn't surprised. Being the film
buff that I am, I still journeyed to the theater - barf bag in-hand
- but with, admittedly, low expectations.
Surprise! Those low expectations (and the fact that Spielberg
mercifully turned over the directing duties to Joe Johnston) allowed
me to enjoy JP3 to a greater
extent than The Lost World,
and I actually was interested in what was happening on-screen
even if it was merely a derivative plot being propped on the back of
the mighty dinos. For you see, the story of JP3
is about as thin as you can get. Our fearless hero from the first
JP, Dr. Alan Grant (once again
played by the deliciously wry Sam Neill), is suckered into going
back to the land of the dinos - which at this point in the
JP "universe" is
common knowledge to everyone on the planet - to rescue the son of a
divorced couple played by Tea Leoni and William H. Macy. Of course,
the couple brings along a few other tough guys to help them "negotiate"
with the hungry locals, but any viewer who has seen more than three
action movies knows full well that these peripheral characters serve
no more a purpose than mozzarella stick appetizers. Oh, did I
mention that the kid ended up stranded on the island because he went
parasailing over very hostile, abstruse territory with the
lame-brained boyfriend of his mother? I have two words for you: "dumb"
and "asses."
And that's about it. In between a few meaningless lines of dialog,
and some rather flimsy attempts at building characters and
relationships, we get the latest and greatest dino action ILM and
Stan Winston Studios has to offer. But before you say, "Been
there, done that," know that this is exactly why
JP3 is superior in every way
to The Lost World. The first
JP film succeeded (at least
with me) because not only did Spielberg dazzle us with an orgy of
sights and sounds we only dreamed of as little kids, but the
underlying moral lessons of the potential dangers of playing God
with genetics made for a complete experience. With
The Lost World, what fans were
offered was an overly long, 2+ hour rehash of the original, whose
only saving grace was the all too brief ending in the streets of San
Diego. There wasn't any great lesson to learn, necause we had seen
it all before. Spielberg really had nothing to say with the film.
Okay, so JP3 might seem to
have fallen into the same trap, but what Johnston realized was that
the opportunity to preach any kind of meaningful lesson was
exhausted in the first film, so learn from the disastrous sequel and
just make a kick-ass popcorn film. And he made it so.
JP3 works because it knows
what it is, and it's perfectly content with being a simple dino
extravaganza/action-fest - no more, no less. This time, the raptors
are more wicked (although suspiciously more intelligent than many of
the film's human characters), the T-Rex is no longer the baddest
dude in the whole damn jungle (that honor now belongs to the super
huge Spinosaur). And, ladies and gentlemen, we finally have
Pteredons. And the absolute best part? The film is only 88 minutes
without closing credits! A merciful 88 minutes! Johnston wasted no
time in showing us the new dinos, putting the characters into
exciting action sequences, and wrapping the whole thing up right
before it became tedious. But despite these improvements, it's still
a Jurassic Park film, so the "been
there, done that" stigma applies to a certain extent. Spielberg
has expressed interest in a fourth installment, and if anyone were
to ask me, I'd say expand on the idea of dinos in the big city, as
expressed by the San Diego sequence in the second film. The big city
is a fresh setting for the franchise and would do a lot to
reinvigorate the series. No more jungles please!
As is to be expected of a recent high-budget action/adventure film,
the 1.85:1 anamorphic widescreen transfer on this DVD looks great.
Despite being packed with enough extra features and sound options to
warrant a 2-disc set, the transfer remains solid with very minor
compression artifacting and, thankfully, very minimal edge
enhancement. Colors are nicely rendered with good saturation, and
black levels are deep and pure. No complaints here.
Not to expect anything less than the best in the audio department,
the Dolby Digital 5.1 soundtrack is grand and exciting. The entire
soundstage is utilized to present an aggressive, immersive mix. Low
frequencies are robust, while the subtle sounds of the distant
jungle wildlife float in the air. Expect plenty of directional
panning during the heavier moments, and clearly intelligible dialog
during the occasional quieter passages. The alternate DTS 5.1 track
betters its Dolby roommate a tiny bit with more transparent
subtleties in the ambiance, and slightly tighter low frequencies. If
you have a DTS set-up, this is the preferred choice, but don't fret
if you're only Dolby-equipped, because both are first-rate
experiences.
I'll tell you, Universal could have made life a lot easier by
consolidating the innumerable little featurettes found scattered
throughout the special features section of this disc into one,
continuous documentary. This is a trend I've been noticing over the
last year or so that absolutely drives me up the wall, and Universal
is one of the main offenders. The supplemental features on this disc
are largely informative, and worth the time to look at (DVD special
edition producer extraordinaire Laurent Bouzereau is responsible for
most of the disc's content), but the featurettes prove very tedious
to work through. There are legal (and in turn monetary) issues
studios must contend with if a DVD documentary is over 30 minutes in
length, but for marquee special edition discs (like a
Jurassic Park film, or
The Mummy Returns for
instance), I would think that it's worth the extra money it takes to
put something of that length together. But anyway, let's get to it,
shall we?
First up is a commentary track with the key special effects team
members (including Stan Winston, John Rosengrant, Dan Taylor and
Michael Lanteri). The track is wholly technical, yet informative. It
doesn't cover much about plot and character development, but
(cough) The Making of Jurassic Park III
is a 25-minute featurette containing interviews with the cast, crew
and producer Kathleen Kennedy. It's quite amusing to watch the
participants tout the merits of the film's story and characters, but
the piece offers some interesting technical behind-the-scenes
snippets. The New Dinosaurs of Jurassic
Park III featurette is a 5-minute look at the new and
improved dinos in the film. Notable to this featurette are interview
segments with renowned paleontologist Jack Horner. The
Montana: Finding New Dinosaurs
featurette runs another 5 minutes and again features Horner, but
this time on location at a dino dig in Montana.
A Visit to ILM is the point in
the supplements where I start getting frustrated. This is basically
a series of vignettes (including Concepts,
The Process,
Muscle Simulation and
Compositing) that run
approximately 15 minutes when combined. They are all very neat,
informative little pieces, that are fairly self-explanatory for the
purposes here, but Universal failed to include a "Play All"
function to make the overall series come together seamlessly. A
second series of behind-the-scenes vignettes (including
A Visit to Stan Winston Studios,
Spinosaurs Attack the Plane,
Raptors Attack Udesky and
The Lake) come next, and run
approximately 13 minutes when put together. But again, keep that
remote handy because the segments lack a "Play All"
feature. Each vignette is a repository of behind-the-scenes peeks at
how the technology came together and integrated with the practical
effects to create the finished product. Three storyboard-to-feature
comparisons are included, as well as dinosaur turntables that
highlight several of the film's dino species in a 360-degree view,
along with the animals' physical specs. A gallery of production
photos, posters, cast and crew bios and production notes are also
included. And then we have the requisite Universal Studios
promotional blather including promos for the Jurassic
Park III soundtrack, Universal Studios Theme Parks, an
amazingly dopey Scan Command: Jurassic
Park III game promo, JP Institute promo, DVD
recommendations and a promo for Universal's newsletter. Theatrical
trailers for all three Jurassic
films can be found too, as well as disappointing PCFriendly DVD-ROM
material (including Universal web links, screensavers and game
demos). All in all, the supplements on this disc are good despite
the vignette structures and the usual Universal promo fluff. If
you're fascinated with the world of cinema special effects, you'll
have a blast, but you'll have to work for it.
Jurassic Park III is something
of a double-edged sword. There's not much of a plot and you really
don't give a damn about the characters (unlike the original film).
But at least JP3 is well aware
of that fact, and instead provides new dinos and a much brisker pace
(which is what the second installment sorely lacked). For a mindless
action/adventure effects-fest, there are worse examples out there,
but just keep in mind that JP3
is not the film that will redefine or reinvigorate this series.
Greg Suarez
gregsuarez@thedigitalbits.com |
Jurassic
Park III: Collector's Edition (Widescreen)
|
|