Site created 12/15/97. |
|
review added: 9/8/00
updated: 8/2/01
Jurassic Park
review by Bill Hunt, editor of
The Digital Bits
|
|
Jurassic
Park
Collector's Edition - 1993 (2000)
- Amblin (Universal)
Film Rating: B+
Disc Ratings (Video/Audio/Extras): A/A/A
Specs and Features
127 mins, PG-13, letterboxed widescreen (1.85:1), 16x9 enhanced, single-sided,
RSDL dual-layered (layer switch at 38:06, at the start of chapter 8), Amaray
keep case packaging, The Making of Jurassic Park
documentary, video of early pre-production meetings, Spielberg's location
scouting video, Phil Tippett animatic for "Raptors in the Kitchen"
scene, gallery of storyboards for 5 scenes (including an omitted scene and the
film's original ending), foley artists video, stills gallery (with production
photos, design sketches and conceptual paintings), 3 theatrical trailers (for
Jurassic Park I, II
& III), dino encyclopedia, production
notes, cast & filmmaker bios, DVD newsletter offer, DVD-ROM materials
(including film-themed screen saver and web browser with links to official site
and live JP III events), animated
film-themed menu screens with sound and music, scene access (20 chapters),
languages: English (DD 5.1) and French (DD 3.0), subtitles: English &
Spanish
|
|
|
Jurassic
Park (DTS)
Collector's Edition - 1993 (2000)
- Amblin (Universal)
Film Rating: B+
Disc Ratings (Video/Audio/Extras): A/A+
(see updates)/C-
Specs and Features
127 mins, PG-13, letterboxed widescreen (1.85:1), 16x9 enhanced, single-sided,
RSDL dual-layered (layer switch at 38:06, at the start of chapter 8), Amaray
keep case packaging, The Making of Jurassic Park
documentary, 3 theatrical trailers (for Jurassic Park
I, II & III),
dino encyclopedia, production notes, cast & filmmaker bios, DVD newsletter
offer, DVD-ROM materials (including film-themed screen saver and web browser
with links to official site and live JP III
events), animated film-themed menu screens with sound and music, scene access
(20 chapters), languages: English (DTS 5.1 & DD 2.0), subtitles: English,
French & Spanish
|
Note:
We have updated this review to include some comments on the DTS audio version of
Jurassic Park - look for that at the end of this text.
Remember back in early 1997, when DVD was still only available in a few test
markets? It was all we could do then to dream of the day when films like Jurassic
Park would be released on our favorite format. Well, that day has
finally arrived and the only really sad thing about it is that so many good
movies are being released on DVD now that for many, affording them all means
taking a second job! These are very good times indeed for DVD fans.
I remember vividly the first time I saw Jurassic
Park. I caught it at the Edwards "Big" Newport theater in
Newport Beach, CA., which I believe still boasts the largest movie screen west
of the Mississippi. It was a weekday and I had skipped out early on work. So,
apparently, had lots of other people - the line for the 11 AM show went way
around the block. The theater had even rented a massive, inflatable Godzilla and
had erected it on top of the building. The place was a zoo, the atmosphere was
edge-of-your-seat... and the crowd wasn't disappointed. There have only been two
times when a movie has just rocked my world. The first time was Star
Wars. The second was Jurassic Park.
It wasn't so much that Jurassic Park is a
great film, because it isn't (I'll explain that more in a minute). But when I
was a kid, nothing was as cool to me as dinosaurs. I had books, plastic toy
dinos, I could even name all the different kinds. And as far as I was concerned,
this was as close as I was ever gonna get to seeing real, living breathing
dinosaurs. That just blew me away.
The film's story is based on a novel by tech-savvy author Michael Crichton. It
seems that an ambitious business magnate and showman named Hammond (played by
director Richard Attenborough) has built the ultimate theme park on a Pacific
island off the coast of Costa Rica - one in which the featured attraction is
nothing less than real live dinosaurs. He's found their DNA in the stomachs of
prehistoric insects trapped in amber, and his scientists have used it to clone
new living creatures. But there's been an accident at his new park, which is
close to opening, so his financial backers have demanded that he get a handful
of experts to sign off on the park's safety. Hammond treks to Montana to enlist
the aid of paleontologist Alan Grant (Sam Neill) and paleobotanist Ellie Sattler
(Laura Dern). Hammond offers to fund their research if they'll visit his island
for a weekend and they agree... having no idea what they're getting into. Also
along for the ride are an expect on Chaos theory (Jeff Goldblum), a lawyer
representing the money interests (Martin Ferrero) and Hammond's two young
grandchildren. Naturally, they're all astounded at the dinosaurs they see when
they arrive, but it doesn't take long for things to start going wrong when they
embark on a guided tour of the park. And when an approaching tropical storm and
a little old-fashioned, greed-motivated sabotage get thrown into the mix, the
visitors soon find themselves in a fight for survival on an island where
everything seems determined to eat them.
There's just no way you can understate this - Jurassic
Park marks a landmark achievement in the history of film. For the
first time, special effects technicians, filmmakers and real world scientists
collaborated to use Computer Generated Imagery (CGI) to create fully-digital
(and fully-believable) characters on film on a vast scale. And like George Lucas
before him, Spielberg's creation changed everything - no longer were filmmakers
constrained by the practical constraints of filmmaking. In this new digital age,
if you can imagine it, you can bring it to life.
The film's historical impact aside, the other thing that makes Jurassic
Park so interesting is the sheer creative talent involved. You've got
direction by Steven Spielberg, you've got special effects by the best wizards in
the biz - Dennis Muren, Stan Winston and Phil Tippett (all working for this
project under the roof of Lucas's Industrial Light & Magic). You've got a
Michael Crichton story, you've got music by John Williams. How could this not be
a huge hit? Interestingly, however, it's the sheer commercial perfectness that
hamstrings the film. Did anyone else groan at the obvious product placements for
Continental Airlines, Jolt Cola, Barbasol shaving cream (and the list goes on
and on)? Worst of all is the blatant plug for Jurassic
Park merchandise itself - lunch boxes, T-shirts, stuffed dinos...
they're all there. It wouldn't have been so bad, except that we all knew those
products were real - we had seen carts full of the stuff for sale in the lobby
on the way into the theater! I don't think I've ever had the experience before
of seeing a movie on the first showing on opening day where people in the
audience were ALREADY wearing T-shirts with the movie's logo on them. Surreal.
Commercialism aside, I must also confess that the whole Reddy Kilowatt-style DNA
animation/exposition sequence grates heavy on my nerves. Still, watching Jurassic
Park makes for an undeniably fun 2 hours in the dark. This is the
ultimate B-movie - the motion picture turned roller coaster ride. Throw in the
fact that this was the world's first DTS sound-encoded movie, and a bag of
popcorn, and you've got some serious fun. Hell... I saw this film 4 times in the
theater. And you know what? I've watched this new DVD twice already. So who
cares if it isn't Lawrence of Arabia?
Those are dinosaurs, man!
So how's it look on DVD? Bottom line - the anamorphic widescreen video is
excellent overall. It absolutely doesn't disappoint. There is some very light
edge-enhancement visible occasionally, along with a little bit of digital
artifacting in some of the scenes that take place at night and particularly in
the rain. And you might notice the print looking a little soft at times. But
those are tiny nits to pick. The colors are always rich and accurate, black
levels are very nicely rendered and there's very good detail throughout the
presentation. This is very close to reference quality - not quite there, but
definitely in the ballpark. I must say I'm looking forward to scanning the
newsgroups when this title streets, and reading the inevitable, "OH MY GOD
- THIS IS THE BEST VIDEO EVER!!" comments. Like I said - expectations are
running a tad on the high side. In any case, it's extremely easy to be thrilled
with this DVD picture. And I am.
The disc's Dolby Digital 5.1 audio mix is even better. What really surprised me
was the tremendous dynamic range this mix represents. Everything sounds
wonderful here, from the quietest jungle whispers and the patter of rainfall to
the screeching raptors and the ear-shattering roar of the T-Rex. This is no
gimmicky-sounding 5.1 mix - the use of panning and rear channel audio is very
appropriate to the visuals and is very natural sounding. Whether it's the
chirping of a tiny dino as it runs past behind you, or the sound of the Rex's
screams up front echoing from the rear channels as if it's reflecting back from
the forest behind you, this mix is completely believable. Dialogue is
wonderfully clear and clean, ambiences are nicely rendered (the inside of the
tour cars in the rain, for example) and the Rex's footsteps will test your
system's capacity to deliver low frequency. The only thing that could be better
than this would be the DTS version, and you can be sure we'll review that as
soon as we can get our hands on it.
I also have to say that I'm very impressed with the quality and efficiency of
the extras on this disc. Jurassic Park
could easily have been designed as a 2-disc set on DVD, and no doubt many are
wondering why a film like Titus would get
the 2-disc treatment while this film must make do with a single disc. But I
think those concerns are largely moot. I was very satisfied with the supplements
this DVD delivers. First of all, the 50-minute documentary that's included on
this disc, The Making of Jurassic Park,
answered almost every question I had about the film. It's hosted by James Earl
Jones, and features interviews with everyone important to the production.
Spielberg is so prevalent here, and gives so much interesting information and
insight, that I didn't even balk at the fact that there's no audio commentary on
the disc. We learn here that Spielberg first became interested in directing the
project before Crichton had even finished the book... and that he actually
storyboarded scenes from the finished novel before a script was written. We
learn of the moment that stop/go-motion animation pioneer Phil Tippett feared
his talents were passe (incorrectly but understandably) when he saw that CGI
could replace what he'd been hired to do. We see the CGI animators taking mime
classes to learn how dinosaurs would have acted. We see Stan Winston's
full-size, mechanical Rex getting waterlogged after a long day's filming in the
rain. It's all here in the documentary - everything I wanted and more.
But that's not all - the DVD delivers plenty more. We get to see 6 minutes of
video of early pre-production meetings, where Spielberg, Tippett, Winston, Muren
and others talk about how the dinos should look and move. We see a couple of
minutes of Spielberg's own hand-held video footage taken while scouting
locations in Hawaii. We get a gallery of literally dozens of production photos,
design sketches and conceptual partings. There are dozens more storyboards, from
5 different scenes in the film, including an omitted scene and the film's
original ending. There's one of Phil Tippett's complete go-motion "animatics",
which was done to show CGI animators (and Spielberg) how the "raptors in
the kitchen" scene would flow dramatically and how the timing should work
for effects. You get theatrical trailers for this film and Jurassic
Park II, as well as a teaser trailer for JP
III. You get a mini-encyclopedia of the dinosaurs in the film,
production notes and cast & crew bio information. And via DVD-ROM, you get a
film-themed screen saver and web browser with links to a Jurassic
Park website (and eventual "live event" access to the set
of Jurassic Park III, which is currently
in production). Could they have found more to include on a 2-disc set? Sure. I
could easily have watched all of Phil Tippett's animatics. A printable
screenplay would have been great. And sure... audio commentaries would have been
welcomed. But here's the point - I didn't MISS any of those things. What you do
get is so comprehensive in terms of answering all your questions and covering
all the different aspects of the production, that more isn't necessary. And THAT
is the mark of a good DVD special edition.
Universal has accomplished a very tall order - meeting our lofty expectations
for Jurassic Park on DVD. Could they have
made this a more elaborate set? Sure. But I don't think that anyone is going to
be disappointed. I certainly wasn't. This special edition delivered pretty much
everything I wanted to know about the amazing achievement of bringing dinosaurs
to life on film. The documentary alone would have made me happy and the rest is
just candy. This is definitely a disc to savor. And why not? We've certainly
waited long enough for it. ;-)
10/20/00 - DTS Update
We've taken the time to compare the regular collector's edition (reviewed
above) with the DTS audio version, and some of you are going to be a little
surprised. Usually, we tend to prefer the DTS audio versions of our favorite
DVDs, but not in this case. The DTS track does deliver the usual improvements in
resolution. These include a bigger, wider soundstage, with greater clarity and
more natural rendition of atmosphere. Panning is smoother and music and dialogue
seem to come alive. But the big problem with this track is a decided lack of low
frequency. I've heard a lot of others complaining about this on the newsgroups,
and I can only agree. When I listened to this film in DTS sound in the theaters,
I could actually feel the bass in my chest. No one expects quite that same
sensation in the living room, but I was surprised that there was so little low
frequency as to be actually distracting. The Dolby Digital version of this disc
resonates with bass - not so the DTS. This was the first DTS film in theaters
and I wanted to be blown away with the DTS sound on DVD. I wasn't. Add to that
the fact that the addition of the DTS track meant the removal of virtually all
substantial bonus material other than the making-of documentary and... well, our
recommendation is to buy the Dolby Digital version.
8/2/01 - DTS Update
There is now conclusive proof that the first pressings of the DTS DVD version
of Jurassic Park featured defective 5.1
audio - Universal has quietly corrected the DTS sound and re-pressed the disc.
The new pressing of this disc is now starting to appear in stores. The
difference in the low frequency sound between the fixed and original defective
discs is startling. Whereas before, I had to manually adjust both my receiver
and subwoofer to obtain any kind of worthwhile bass, this new disc simply
rumbles with it. My subwoofer is now far more active - THIS is the audio
experience I recall from the theater. The new DTS audio easily rates an A+ for
quality.
Unfortunately, there is no sure-fire way to identify the new disc from its
packaging alone. The original release of the disc had two stickers on the front,
one which promoted the Jurassic Park III
weblinks the disc provided, and one which promoted the discs PlayStation 2
compatibility. Some people are reporting that the new discs don't have the PS2
sticker. Mine didn't have either. One thing you should look for is the spine
label at the top of the keepcase - on the new discs, it should read: Jurassic
Park (WS) (DTS). That said, THE ONLY SURE WAY TO IDENTIFY THE FIXED
VERSION IS BY THE NUMBERS ON THE INSIDE RING OF THE ACTUAL DISC. The FIXED disc
will read: PEMC-D2R2. The earlier
pressings - the defective ones - read either PEMC-D2R0
or PEMC-D2R1. Note that it's our belief
that the DTS version of The Lost World
does not share this defect.
We are working to get some answers, as well as a way consumers can exchange
their defective discs. Keep checking back for updates.
Bill Hunt
billhunt@thedigitalbits.com |
Jurassic Park
Jurassic Park (DTS)
|
|