Classic
Reviews Roundup #7 - July 2004
May seems to be war month for most of the major releasers so this
outing of the Classic Reviews Round-Up
covers a number of such offerings related to 20th century wars from
Warner Bros. (Back to Bataan,
Battleground, The
Flying Leathernecks), Fox (Crash
Dive, The Enemy Below,
The Hunters, Morituri,
What Price Glory), MGM (Hell
in the Pacific, The Last
Valley, Too Late the Hero),
and Paramount (The Winds of War).
We also go back to wars prior to the 20th century to look at The
300 Spartans (Fox), Helen of
Troy (WB), and The Last Valley
(MGM). The reviews are ordered by releasing studio.
Crash Dive (1943)
What Price Glory (1952)
The Enemy Below (1957)
The Hunters (1958)
The 300 Spartans (1962)
Morituri (1965)
(all released on DVD by Fox on May 25th, 2004
This is the fourth wave of war films from Fox and each offering to
date has included a nice variety of items. Settings this time range
from World War I on the ground (What
Price Glory), to World War II on the water (Crash
Dive, The Enemy Below,
Morituri) to the Korean War in
the air (The Hunters). Then we
return to the Greeks and the Persians at Thermopylae (The
300 Spartans).
The class of this wave is The Enemy
Below which, after a false start in 2003, Fox has now
been able to release in Region 1. Its arrival is welcome for it's
one of the more intelligent war films out there. Set in the South
Atlantic during World War II, it pits the captain of an American
destroyer against his counterpart in a German U-boat. The film's
basic premise and the execution of the plot offers little out of the
ordinary for a war film, but the portrayal of the captains is
handled very skillfully and thoughtfully by Robert Mitchum and Curt
Jurgens. Mitchum's character is a former merchant ship's officer
whose loss of that ship prompted him to join the navy so that he
could be "on the shooting rather than receiving end" as he
puts it. At first viewed as a dabbler by his crew, they soon
recognize his level of skill and experience as he continually
manages to match the German captain's own expertise. Mitchum gives
his character his standard blend of easy-going yet ultimately
forceful professionalism. Jurgens' German captain is a more
introspective man, a veteran of World War I submarine warfare and
now a professional naval officer who questions the merits and
ultimate success of the German war effort. Both men prove to be
reluctant warriors who know they are just doing a job the best they
can and both in the end recognize each other's strength. The work of
Mitchum and Jurgens elevates the film above many of its
contemporaries and makes it still well worth seeing. The
Enemy Below was directed by Dick Powell who by the
mid-1950s had for the most part withdrawn from acting to concentrate
on behind-the-camera activities. He co-founded "Four Star
Television" which produced a number of anthology-type programs
such as Four Star Playhouse
and The Dick Powell Show.
Powell was also the director of The
Conqueror (1956) filmed near a Utah atomic test site and
a film that saw many of its participants, including its star, John
Wayne, suffer cancer in later years. Powell's direction of The
Enemy Below is assured, as he handles dialogue and action
scenes equally efficiently. Look for future television stars David
Hedison (billed as Al Hedison) and Doug McClure (unbilled) in
supporting roles. Fox presents the CinemaScope film in a 2.35:1
anamorphic transfer that looks excellent in all respects from colour
fidelity to black levels and shadow detail to lack of age-related
debris. The Dolby 4.0 sound is also quite effective with some
noticeable if subtle use of the surrounds. Spanish and French mono
tracks as well as English and Spanish subtitles are provided.
Supplements consist of three Movietone newsreels related to wartime
U-boat action, the theatrical trailer, and trailers for other Fox
war classics. Recommended.
Crash Dive is the only film of
the group made during the Second World War and its ending offers the
usual boosterism for the fighting forces. Tyrone Power headlines the
cast playing one of his typical God's-gift-to-women roles. The only
problem this time is that the woman he's after (played by Anne
Baxter) is the sweetheart of the captain (Dana Andrews) of the
submarine he's assigned to. Aside from this back story, there's
considerable submarine action as Power and Andrews' ship attempts to
find and destroy a secret German naval base in the North Atlantic.
The action is excitingly staged by veteran director Archie Mayo. The
studios commonly tried to dress up some of their wartime propaganda
films with Technicolor (such as Dive
Bomber and Captains of the
Clouds, from Warners, and Halls
of Montezuma from Fox). Crash
Dive, despite its predictable plot, didn't really need
the colour boost due to its fine star power and action, but it
provides one extra reason to enjoy the film. Fox's full-frame
transfer (in accord with the original theatrical ratio) is a very
good one. The source material is obviously in very good shape and
the result is a vibrant, finely detailed image with only minor
debris and speckling. The only deficiency is a couple of short
sequences where colour fidelity wavers somewhat. The Dolby stereo
sound is adequate with clear dialogue and decent presence during the
action scenes. Mono tracks and sub-titles are provided in both
English and Spanish. The only supplements are the theatrical trailer
and trailers for other Fox war classics. Recommended.
What Price Glory was based on
the Maxwell Anderson play that first had a good stage run in
1924-1925 and then was made into a film starring Victor McLaglen in
1926. Its story involves the relationship between two soldiers,
Captain Flagg and Sergeant Quirt, and their mutual interest in a
French village woman. With as much comedy as tragedy about the
futility of war, the play and film were both high points of the
1920s. Fox decided to remake the film in the early 1950s as a
musical and interested James Cagney in portraying Captain Flagg
because of the musical approach. John Ford agreed to direct due to
his personal fondness for the play, but when he heard about the
musical idea, he rejected it flatly. As a result, Cagney was
unhappy, but he had a contract for this one picture so he toughed it
out. The results are not happy. Both Cagney and his co-star (Dan
Dailey as Quirt) were generally allowed to ham it up by Ford and the
play's balance between comedy and tragedy suffers fatally. Instead
of "war is hell", it seemed too much like "war is a
hell of a good time". Of course, no Cagney film is without
value for his presence elevates anything he's in, but on the whole
it was a "miss' during a decade of hit and miss films. Fox
continues its winning steak with another very fine image transfer.
The full frame rendition (in accord with the original aspect ratio)
of the Technicolor film is very bright and clean with vibrant colour
(almost too much so for some of the subject matter), deep blacks,
good shadow detail, and minimal dirt and debris. The Dolby stereo
sound is in good shape with clear dialogue and some presence to the
war scenes. English and Spanish mono tracks and sub-titles are
provided. Supplements consist of a theatrical teaser and trailer,
and trailers for other Fox war classics.
Lately, Robert Wagner seems to be everywhere when it comes to Fox
releases from the 1950s. Prince Valiant,
Let's Make It Legal, What
Price Glory, and now The
Hunters all offered him substantial parts. In the latter
he's a hot-shot rookie pilot during the Korean War, who must help
his commanding officer (Robert Mitchum) effect a daring rescue of
his commander's wingman (Lee Phillips) who has been shot down behind
enemy lines. Mitchum of course is the star of the film and he gets
involved with his wingman's wife (Mai Britt) as a complication to
the whole situation. Mitchum is his usual effective self; Wagner
gives a strong if predictable performance; and the film builds some
decent tension courtesy of tight direction by Dick Powell. Yet,
there's a general feeling of having-seen-it-all-before about this
one that isn't entirely overcome by the cast and director's efforts.
The film's real highlight is the photography of the aerial
sequences. Fox's 2.35:1 anamorphic transfer is another winner
overall although problematic flesh tones from time to time are
somewhat intrusive. Colours have good fidelity; blacks are deep; and
shadow detail is very good. The flip side of the disc contains a
useless full-frame version of the film. Dirt and debris are minimal.
The Dolby 4.0 sound is very effective with noticeable use of the
surrounds, some decent presence to the action scenes, and otherwise
clear dialogue. English and Spanish sub-titles are provided.
Supplements consist of a Movietone newsreel on the film's premiere,
a teaser and trailer, and trailers for other Fox war classics.
Morituri (later also known as
Saboteur: Code Name Morituri)
was a nautical reunion of sorts for producer Aaron Rosenberg, Marlon
Brando, and Trevor Howard. The three had been central to the 1962
remake of Mutiny on the Bounty.
In Morituri, the setting was
the Second World War with Brando as an agent (with a German
background) for the British aboard a German freighter transporting a
valuable cargo of rubber across the Pacific. Brando (who has been
coerced into his espionage role by a British Intelligence officer
(Howard, in a small role) must battle through a cat and mouse game
with the ship's captain (a "good" German played by Yul
Brynner) and the ship's first officer ( a confirmed Nazi, played by
Martin Benrath). The film is a thinking man's wartime espionage tale
that gradually transforms what appears to be a straight-forward task
for Brando into a complicated web of treachery. The suspense is
built convincingly by German director Bernard Wicki (who ironically
was accused by Brando of being too perfectionistic with his numerous
takes for some scenes). Notable in the film is its fine black and
white photography by Conrad Hall. Of the main players, the honours
go to Yul Brynner. Brando's efforts were at least an improvement
over his previous outing (Bedtime Story). Fox's 1.85:1 anamorphic
transfer is quite decent-looking. Shadow detail is good and the
image is generally quite sharp, but the overall sense is of a
slightly gray image characterized by a lack of deep blacks. The
Dolby stereo sound is in reasonable shape with clear dialogue and
some degree of presence in the action sequences. English and Spanish
mono tracks and sub-titles are provided. Supplements consist of a
theatrical teaser and trailer, and trailers for other Fox war
classics. Recommended.
At a time when ancient history is being re-fought on the screen in
the likes of Gladiator, Troy,
and the forthcoming Alexander,
it's appropriate to see how Hollywood was handling such events some
40 years ago. The 300 Spartans,
from 1962, gives us Richard Egan, Ralph Richardson, and Diane Baker
starring in a recreation of the resistance of a brave band of 300
Spartans who attempt to hold back the Persian army intent on
invading Greece at Thermopylae during the 5th century B.C. Egan
plays Leonidas, the head of the brave Spartans while Richardson is
Themistocles of Athens. At the time of the event, Greece was a
collection of city states of which Athens and Sparta were the main
ones. The film gives some flavour of the inter-city-state rivalries
involved and the use of Greek location shooting adds authenticity,
but the whole effort is just a little too talky (with some rather
wooden acting) and bland. Even the climactic battle scenes lack real
drama, aside from the initial shot of the wedge of Spartans
intersecting the Persian army. The colourful wide screen boasts some
impressive-looking images (probably equally attributable to
cinematographer Geoffrey Unsworth and director Rudolph Maté,
a former cinematographer), but the film never conveys the scope of a
true epic. At least Fox's 2.35:1 anamorphic transfer shows it all in
its best light. The image is bright and colourful with deep blacks
and good shadow detail. There is some minor speckling and a bit of
grain, but overall fans of the film will be very pleased. The Dolby
stereo sound is unremarkable, but is at least free of age-related
defects such as hiss or distortion. English and Spanish mono tracks
and sub-titles are provided. Supplements consist of three TV
promotional teasers, English and Spanish theatrical trailers, and
trailers for three other Fox historical epics.
Hell in the Pacific (1968)
The Last Valley (1970)
Too Late the Hero (1970)
(all released on DVD by MGM on May 25th, 2004)
These are all titles previously released on DVD by Anchor Bay in
2001 when that company had gained the rights from Disney. With that
agreement now expired and a new one in place between Disney and MGM,
we now have the three films available under the MGM imprimatur. That
means some nice new transfers, right? Wrong, these are the same old,
same old; so if you have the Anchor Bay efforts, you can save
yourself some money here.
The best film of this bunch has perversely the poorest of the DVD
transfers. The Last Valley was
conceived as a major epic in the twilight days of the road show
presentation, but the background canvas of the 30 Years War in the
17th century is only vaguely sketched in, so that rather than an
epic tale, we get a more intimate, contained story. That's not a
complaint, for the result is an engrossing character study of how
men adapt their ways of life and their own existence to fit
circumstance, but how little impact those efforts may have in the
end. The Last Valley is
literally a secluded alpine valley that has managed to avoid the
terror and rape of pillaging armies and soldiers of fortune that
characterize both sides of the sectarian conflict of the 30 Years
War. Then one such group of men led by the Captain stumbles on the
valley, but is dissuaded from destroying its inhabitants and their
homes by Vogel, a teacher who is on the run from the War and has
himself come upon the valley by chance. Instead, convinced to treat
the valley as a winter way station, the Captain finds himself caught
up in the valley's life and the intrigues of its inhabitants.
Michael Caine gives an introspective, yet quietly forceful
performance as the Captain while Omar Sharif portrays the enigmatic
Vogel. The story has the typical intelligence of a James Clavell
script. As director, Clavell also manages to convey the
claustrophobic nature of the secluded valley, but some abrupt cuts
in the completed film hint at the more epic sweep originally
intended. Despite that, the results provide a thoughtful film
experience that goes beyond the genre's norm. Unfortunately, the
film experience on DVD (2.35:1, but not anamorphically enhanced) is
disappointing. The image is inconsistent - bright, colourful, and
sharp in one sequence, then dull and washed-out in another. Grain is
excessive, and motion artifacts are annoyingly common. The mono
sound is clear enough, but only hints at the fidelity of John
Barry's fine score. English, French, and Spanish sub-titles are
provided. There are no supplements.
Hell in the Pacific tells a
Robinson-Crusoe-like tale of a Japanese and an American soldier,
both stranded on an otherwise deserted island in the Pacific during
the Second World War. As presented, the story is more about how the
two come to accommodate each other's presence than about the
mechanics of personal survival in such circumstances. Toshiro Mifune
and Lee Marvin both give convincing performances and the film
presents each player's dialogue only in their native language so
that the audience can identify most closely with the difficulties of
whichever character speaks their language. The situation has
considerable initial novelty, but the film loses steam about
half-way through. Only when the characters manage to contrive a way
to get off the island is momentum regained. The ending is abrupt and
will likely provide mixed emotions. An alternate ending (reportedly
director John Boorman's original choice) provided as a supplement on
the DVD is equally ambivalent. The 2.35:1 image transfer, despite
not being anamorphically enhanced, looks fairly sharp with only
modest dirt and debris in evidence. Colours are natural although not
as lush-looking as the setting might suggest they would be. There is
modest grain present on occasion. The mono sound is quite adequate
for this dialogue-driven film. A Japanese mono track and English,
French, and Spanish sub-titles are also provided. The only
supplement is an alternate ending, as mentioned above.
Too Late the Hero is a Pacific
island World War II story of a more conventional type. Cliff
Robertson plays reluctant American soldier Lieutenant Sam Lawson who
is loaned to the British because of his Japanese language skills.
Lawson's assignment is to accompany a British patrol that is to
infiltrate the Japanese position on the island the British and
Japanese jointly hold, and destroy the Japanese communications
system. The British squad, generally composed of malcontents, is
commanded by mild-mannered Captain Hornsby (Denholm Elliott) and
includes the cynical Private Tosh Hearne (Michael Caine). Hearne and
Lawson eventually find themselves tossed together to ensure the
carrying out of the patrol's task. The film is directed by Robert
Aldrich and bears the stamp of his typically successful and
action-oriented war films, but in this instance is undermined by a
plot full of implausibilities (unnecessary open field crossings,
failures by the Japanese to carry out obvious ways to subvert the
patrol's progress in particular and the British presence on the
island in general, a ridiculous loudspeaker network, etc.). If you
can overlook those, however, you will find the film diverting if
predictable, with fine performances by both Caine and Robertson. The
supporting work by Denholm Elliott and familiar British character
actors such as Ian Bannen and Harry Andrews is also a plus. The tale
is obviously a comment on the Vietnam War which was becoming
increasingly unpopular at the time, and the title shot of the
gradually decaying Japanese, British, and American flags gives us an
inkling of the viewpoint to expect. Watch also for Henry Fonda in a
small supporting role. MGM's DVD release provides a 1.78:1
anamorphic transfer which appears to be correctly framed (although
for theatrical release, some prints were blown up to 70mm for an
aspect ratio of 2.00:1). The image is generally sharp with good
colour and fine shadow detail. Age-related speckling and some dirt
and debris is in evidence. There are a few instances of edge
effects, but not of significant concern. The mono sound is quite
adequate with clear dialogue and some presence during the action
sequences. English, French, and Spanish sub-titles are provided. The
only supplement is the original theatrical trailer.
The Winds of War (1983)
(released on DVD by Paramount on May 25th, 2004)
Twenty to twenty-five years ago when network television had a much
bigger slice of the television-watching pie, the mounting of
impressive and lengthy mini-series was not uncommon. Perhaps the
most ambitious such effort was the filmization of Herman Wouk's two
best sellers about the Second World War - The
Winds of War and War and
Remembrance. The former consisted of seven parts running
almost 15 hours appeared in 1983 and the latter twelve parts running
almost 25 hours appeared in 1988. Both appeared on ABC and both were
at least partly productions of Paramount Television. Paramount has
now made The Winds of War
available on DVD in a six-disc box set that I highly recommend.
The mini-series is a painless way to gain an appreciation of the
events of World War II as told through the eyes of the Henry family
consisting of Victor "Pug" Henry (a naval officer who
becomes a confidante of President Roosevelt and finds himself
assigned to key centres of the war from Berlin to London to Moscow
to Pearl Harbor), his wife Rhoda, and his three adult children,
Byron, Madeline, and Warren. The power of Wouk's novel is well
preserved, partly because Wouk has adapted his own work for the
film. The cast is well chosen with its main strength lying in its
many supporting characters, particularly Polly Bergen as Rhoda,
Peter Graves as Palmer Kirby, David Dukes as Leslie Slote, Victoria
Tennant as Pamela Tudsbury, and Jan-Michael Vincent as Byron.
Unfortunately the key roles of Pug Henry and Natalie Jastrow (whose
uncle's determination to stay in Italy places her in constant
jeopardy thus drawing in Byron who has fallen in love with her) are
lacking. Robert Mitchum is too old for the part of Pug Henry (as
would be even more obvious in the sequel) although he does bring a
suitable level of gravitas to the role. Ali McGraw as Natalie is a
real disappointment as she too often overacts and fails to convey
why either of Byron or Leslie Slote would be in the slightest
interested in her. Real historical characters are for the most part
well recreated, particularly by Ralph Bellamy as Roosevelt and
Howard Lang as Churchill. Gunter Meisner as Adolf Hitler is less
persuasive, appearing too cartoonish at times.
Director Dan Curtis marshaled the huge cast through an incredibly
complex filming schedule that took place throughout Europe and
America (although mainly in Yugoslavia which was able to stand in
for a number of European locations). Attention to detail was high
and the whole production has a classy look to it. Bob Cobert's
original theme music is very memorable. The overall result is a
particularly adept combination of historical detail and dramatic
back story that takes the time to cover the war's many complexities
and makes it all fascinating. Historical purists may scoff at the
approach, but that's too often a typical reaction of the academic.
Paramount spreads the seven parts over six discs with all
supplementary content placed on the fourth disc. The full frame
image (in accord with the original television presentation) is quite
acceptable. Colours are generally subdued, but the image is crisp
and clear for the most part. There is noticeable grain at times, and
dirt and debris on the source material is more apparent than on most
Paramount efforts. The Dolby mono sound is clear, without apparent
age-related hiss or distortion. English subtitles are provided.
Supplements consist of about an hour and a quarter's worth of new
material spread over four featurettes: Making
The Winds of War, A Novel for
Television, Cast and
Characters, and On Location.
Combined these give a decent appreciation of the effort involved in
the lengthy filming process. Each segment contains new interview
material from the likes of director and producer Dan Curtis,
associate producers Barbara Steele and Branko Lustig, and cast
members Ali McGraw, Peter Graves, Polly Bergen, and Victoria
Tennant. Highly recommended.
As a footnote, readers should be aware that the continuation of the
story, War and Remembrance, is
already available in two box sets from MPI. As I have not seen these
myself, however, I can't comment on their level of quality.
Paramount has no current plans to acquire the rights to War
and Remembrance and issue a DVD set itself.
Back to Bataan (1945)
Battleground (1949)
Flying Leathernecks (1951)
(all released on DVD by Warner Bros. on May 4th, 2004)
Helen of Troy (1955)
(released on DVD by Warner Bros. on April 27th, 2004)
Warners' contribution to the list of new war releases features
three World War II sagas, two of which star John Wayne in
propaganda-type RKO presentations. These are sandwiched around Battleground's
fairly sturdy recreation of one platoon's action during the Battle
of the Bulge, originally released by MGM. Then for a complete change
of pace, we travel back to the time of the Trojan War.
Back to Bataan is the real
flag waver of the group. Conceived just after MacArthur's return to
the Philippines in October 1944, the film extolled the virtues of
the Filipino people and was rushed into production to take advantage
of the steady progress that American and Filipino forces were then
making in reclaiming Bataan and Corregidor from Japanese occupation.
John Wayne stars as an American colonel who acts as liaison with
Filipino regular and guerrilla forces throughout the period from the
fall of Corregidor to the return of American forces and their
freeing of American POWs who had been held captive for up to three
years. Anthony Quinn appears as a captain of the Philippine Scouts.
The story line that involves them unfortunately comes across as
rather muddled as Wayne character keeps popping in and out of the
narrative. Fortunately, the film contains some very good action
sequences, crisply directed by Edward Dmytryk, which help to redeem
it somewhat. The Filipino people are uniformly portrayed as good,
gentle, and courageous, as might be expected, while the Japanese are
predictably shown as completely without redeeming virtue. The likes
of Philip Ahn, Richard Loo, and Abner Biberman were kept busy by
Hollywood throughout the war portraying evil Japanese soldiers and
leaders, and all three are employed in Back
to Bataan to good effect. A nice touch, and one well
received at the time of the film's original release, is the parade
of actual American POWs freed in the Philippines and all identified
by name and place of origin on screen. Overall, however, the film
does not have a great repeat viewing potential. Warner Bros.' DVD
does quite a good job in presenting a fairly crisp image. It's full
frame in accord with the original aspect ratio. Source material dirt
and debris is minor. Black levels are deep; shadow detail is
generally good. The mono sound is in good shape with little evidence
of age-related hiss or distortion. English, French, and Spanish
sub-titles are provided. Uncharacteristically for Warners, there is
no supplementary material whatsoever. For John Wayne fans only.
John Wayne was also a main reason to see 1951's Flying
Leathernecks, an RKO (then under the ownership of Howard
Hughes) film that hoped to capitalize on the popularity of a new
wave of World War II films that began in 1949. In keeping with that
wave, it's less of a flag-waver and more character-driven, although
there are some cold-war (despite the WW2 setting) propaganda-type
utterances. Wayne plays Major Dan Kirby, the new head of a Marine
fighter squadron in the South Pacific. He is a hard man who is
generally disliked by the men under his command, including his
executive officer, Captain Carl Griffin played by Robert Ryan. The
plot follows familiar ground already well harvested by the likes of
Command Decision and Twelve
O'Clock High, but suffers in comparison due to
familiarity and a looser narrative. The film does benefit from some
exciting aerial sequences and the use of Technicolor. The presence
of the under-appreciated Robert Ryan is also a plus, although his
role is too patly written to give him a chance to really shine.
Warner Bros.' DVD does a very fine job with this Technicolor
material although I was thrown off briefly by the appearance of the
RKO logo in black and white to start. The full frame image (in
accord with the OAR) is sharp and nicely detailed with good colour
fidelity. Speckling and debris is minimal. The mono is unremarkable.
English, French, and Spanish sub-titles are provided. The only
supplement is the original theatrical trailer.
Battleground is the best film
of the Warner releases. The film originated with Dore Schary when he
was in charge of production at RKO in 1947. Schary wanted to do a
film that showed that World War II was worth fighting despite the
cost and he settled on the Battle of the Bulge as an appropriate
setting. He commissioned a script from writer Bob Pirosh who had
actually participated in the Battle and Pirosh produced an effort
that focused on the story of one squad during that conflict with the
emphasis on how the men felt and how they were affected by their
experiences. Schary moved over to MGM after Howard Hughes acquired
RKO, taking the Battleground
project with him. MGM contract players Van Johnson, Ricardo
Montalban, John Hodiak, and George Murphy co-starred and veteran
William Wellman was persuaded by both the quality of the script and
a nice chunk of cash to take on the direction. The film premiered in
early November 1949 to both critical and popular acclaim and went on
to become MGM's highest grossing film in five years. It would be
nominated for six Academy Awards, winning for its script and for its
black and white cinematography. Now some 55 years later, the film
retains its power although its premise of following one squad in
action is a much more familiar one to audiences now than it was
then. The acting is sincere and captivating (although it does take a
while to reconcile oneself to seeing MGM's mainly musical players
out of their milieu) while the film has a look of gritty reality to
it even though it was virtually all shot on the MGM back lot. Warner
Bros.' full frame (in accord with the OAR) release looks very good
with only some slight grain to mar the otherwise crisp and clear
image. Shadow detail is very good and source material defects are
minimal. The mono sound track is in good shape with hiss and crackle
virtually absent. English, French, and Spanish sub-titles are also
provided. Supplements consist of a mediocre Pete Smith short Let's
Cogitate and a superior Tex Avery cartoon, Little
Rural Riding Hood. Recommended.
The more one delves into director Robert Wise's career, the more
one realizes how versatile a director he was. From noir to westerns
to musicals to science fiction to horror, he had the touch to make
it work. In 1955, he even tried his hand at historical epic, or in
this case mythological epic, in the filming of Helen
of Troy. The film is a recounting of Homer's "Iliad"
in which the city of Troy is laid siege to by the Greeks because the
Trojan prince Paris returned to Troy after a failed peace mission
but bringing with him Helen, the wife of King Menelaus of Sparta.
The siege, lasting 10 years according to myth, and involving a
thousand Greek ships culminates in the famous Trojan horse ruse. The
film is a fairly successful attempt to translate the familiar story
to the screen. The film holds one's interest, for despite a fairly
superficial script, Wise makes good use of CinemaScope in what would
be his first experience with the new process. He successfully
conveys the scope of the event through the impressive city of Troy,
the massive Greek forces, and well photographed and edited action
sequences. In the latter, he is well aided by veteran second-unit
director Yakima Canutt. Helen (in the person of Rossana Podesta) is
appropriately beautiful, while Paris (Jack Sernas) is impossibly so.
The rest of the cast is an interesting mix, ranging from British
actors Stanley Baker and Harry Andrews (as Achilles and Hector
respectively) to Sir Cedric Hardwicke as a very wise and regal King
Priam of Troy, to American B-movie actors Eduardo Cianelli and Marc
Lawrence as Andros and Diomedes respectively, and even to Brigitte
Bardot in pre-sex kitten days. Filming was done in Rome, with Wise
and about three dozen crew brought in from Warners. Warner Bros.'
DVD of Helen of Troy is a
2.35:1 anamorphic presentation that makes the film look just swell.
The image is crisp and clear with minimal print damage in evidence.
The Warnercolor is quite vibrant and picture detail is very good. A
very nice effort indeed. Warners has also opted for a new Dolby 5.1
sound track that provides some nice presence to the audio and subtle
use of the surrounds. Max Steiner's majestic score is well served,
especially since the film's overture is included. Also included are
a French mono track and English, French, and Spanish sub-titles.
Supplements consist of the theatrical trailer and three Behind
the Cameras segments focusing on the making-of the film.
Hosted by Gig Young, these originally appeared on the Warner
Bros. Presents television series. Totaling less than 20
minutes, these nevertheless do provide a useful contemporary
background to the film-making effort. Recommended.
That's it for now. The next review round-up will either cover a
raft of westerns or several box sets that need my attention.
Barrie Maxwell
barriemaxwell@thedigitalbits.com |