Site
created 12/15/97.
|
page
created: 4/28/05
Back
to Part One
Barrie
Maxwell - Main Page
|
Western
Roundup #1 - April 2005 (continued)
Thunderhead, Son of Flicka
(1945)
(released on DVD by Fox on February 22nd, 2005)
This is the second of three films made in colour by Fox from Mary
O'Hara novels. The first, My Friend
Flicka, proved to be a very successful 1943 adaptation of
the family story about a young boy named Ken McLaughlin and a horse.
Roddy McDowall starred as the boy and Preston Foster and Rita
Johnson appeared as his parents. The same cast was reunited two
years later for Thunderhead - Son of
Flicka. (In 1948, the third film - Green
Grass of Wyoming - appeared, but with an entirely new
cast.)
|
|
In Thunderhead - Son of Flicka,
Ken finds that Flicka has given birth to an albino colt and sets
out to raise the rambunctious creature. First christened Goblin,
but eventually renamed Thunderhead, the colt shows promise as a
racehorse and Ken enters him in a race as a three-year old.
Thunderhead does not win and Ken is injured in the process, but
the horse eventually shows his worth when Ken's life is in
peril, leading to a difficult decision for Ken.
Thunderhead - Son of Flicka
is a worthy follow-up to the original. The story is an
interesting one and the film builds suspense effectively
throughout. Contributing to the latter are the many and varied
horse sequences that are extremely well staged. Extensive
location filming was carried out in Utah, Oregon, California,
and Nevada utilizing the new Technicolor monopack system
completely for the first time. The monopack obviated the need
for the cumbersome three-strip system, although the results on
film did not have quite the same lush colours associated with
the latter. The returning cast is once again appealing,
particularly Roddy McDowall's winning personality.
|
|
Fox's
DVD presentation (correctly framed full screen) is quite nice. The
colours are fairly vibrant with some softness and colour
inconsistency intruding on isolated instances. Film grain is fairly
noticeable. The source material yields only some mild speckling in
the image. Both mono and stereo sound tracks are provided, but
there's little significant difference. Dialogue and sound effects
are clearly audible. A Spanish mono track and English and Spanish
subtitles are also provided. Supplements consist of the original
theatrical trailer and trailers for three other Fox releases.
Recommended.
Red Ryder Double Feature, Volume
7:
Great Stagecoach Robbery
(1945)
Phantom of the Plains
(1945)
Red Ryder Double Feature, Volume
8:
Santa Fe Uprising
(1946)
Devil's Canyon
(1947)
(both released on DVD by VCI on December 28th, 2004)
Republic Pictures was very successful in adapting Fred Harmon's Red
Ryder character to the screen in the 1940s beginning with a serial (Adventures
of Red Ryder) starring Don "Red" Barry in 1940.
Four years later, the studio starred Wild Bill Elliott in its first
series of Red Ryder westerns - 16 in all made in 1944 and 1945.
Elliott made no particular effort to change his normal western
forceful persona to fit the Ryder comic strip character, but the
films were well-made and very popular as a result. A young Robert
Blake co-starred as Little Beaver and Alice Fleming played Ryder's
aunt, the Duchess. Following Elliott's departure into more
prestigious westerns, Allan "Rocky" Lane took over the Red
Ryder role for seven more pictures released during 1946 and 1947,
after which Republic ceased involvement with the character. These
too were good films with Lane providing an enthusiastic
characterization. Robert Blake continued as Little Beaver, but
Margaret Wentworth took over as the Duchess. Two years later,
Eagle-Lion Pictures would make four lesser-regarded Red Ryder
pictures starring Jim Bannon.
|
|
Both
films included in Volume 7 are
Wild Bill Elliott efforts. Great
Stagecoach Robbery (robbery - yes, stagecoach - sort of,
great - no) finds Red Ryder involved in stolen money shipments that
implicate a convict recently released from prison who is attempting
to go straight. The tale includes the shocking (for a B western of
the time) murder of the convict's young grand-daughter. In Phantom
of the Plains (no plains, no phantom), the Duchess is
smitten with a British lord and Red Ryder has to come to her aid
when the lord turns out to be a phony, her money is taken, and her
murder looks to be next. Both films are entertaining B western fare.
While the stories are merely average, Elliott is great as a
no-nonsense Ryder and there are a number of well-staged action
scenes. Too bad you have to put up with the Little Beaver character.
The two films in Volume 8 are
Allan Lane entries. In Rustlers of
Devil's Canyon, Red Ryder, newly returned from the
Spanish-American War, must sort out a conflict between rustlers,
ranchers, and homesteaders. In Santa Fe
Uprising, the Duchess inherits a toll road that a gang of
outlaws is trying to take over. Red has to take on the job of town
sheriff in order to safeguard her interests. Both films are superior
entries, particularly the latter, which makes good use of Barton
MacLane and Jack LaRue as the chief heavies. In both films Allan
Lane is forceful, but also shows some vulnerability in his Ryder
portrayals. The Little Beaver character seems less obtrusive than in
the Volume 7 films. The action
is again well-staged in the usual Republic fashion and both films
benefit from the usual stable of Republic supporting players
including Roy Barcroft, Kenne Duncan, Edmund Cobb, Tom London, and
Dick Curtis.
The source material used for the DVDs appears to be edited
television versions, as each title runs from 52 to 54 minutes - some
4 to 6 minutes shorter than the original release times. VCI's disc
of Volume 7 features transfers
that have a bright image with fairly deep blacks and a reasonable
level of image detail. There are plenty of speckles and scratches,
however, and the disc pauses momentarily several times during the
course of each feature as well as distorting briefly on one
occasion. The Volume 8
transfers are slightly darker resulting in some night-time scenes
that are quite murky. The events of the climactic mine fight in Rustlers
of Devil's Canyon are almost indecipherable as a result.
Volume 8, however, does not
suffer from the pauses that characterize the other disc. The mono
sound on both discs is workable, although there's plenty of hiss,
crackle, and some distortion. Each disc contains similar packages of
supplements - photo galleries of posters, lobby cards, and other Red
Ryder comic strips and books; two chapters of the 1940 Adventures
of Red Ryder serial; decent biographies on the lead
players; and trailers for various Republic B westerns. B western
fans should enjoy either of these discs, but disc quality limits my
recommendation to Volume 8.
The Sundowners (1950)
High Lonesome (1950)
(both released on DVD by VCI on March 29th, 2005)
Alan LeMay is not exactly a Hollywood household name, although
western aficionados will recognize him as the author of the books
from which the films Along Came Jones
(1945), The Searchers (1956)
and The Unforgiven (1960)
derived. Lemay, however, actually had quite a lengthy and generally
successful run in Hollywood as a screenwriter and later a producer
and director. In the 1940s while working mainly at Paramount, he
wrote the screenplays for such films as Reap
the Wild Wind (1942), The
Story of Dr. Wassell (1944), San Antonio (1945), and Tap
Roots (1947). As the 1940s came to a close, LeMay joined
together with director George Templeton to form an independent
production company called Arfran Productions, and thereafter much of
his work focused on the western genre. The immediate fruit of the
new company was the making of two Technicolor westerns both released
in 1950 through Eagle-Lion - The
Sundowners and High Lonesome.
|
|
Both
films are a little out of the ordinary from the usual run of minor-A
westerns. Each certainly offers short bursts of typical western
action, but overall there is a relaxed and thoughtful air to the
presentation of the stories, each of which runs about 82 minutes.
Based on LeMay's 1934 novel "Thunder in the Dust", The
Sundowners (not to be confused with the 1960 film of the
same title set in Australia) tells a fairly complex story of three
brothers, one on the wrong side of the law, who eventually cooperate
in a tale of rustling and murder. Robert Preston stars as the outlaw
brother while Robert Sterling and John Barrymore Jr. (in his debut)
appear as the other two brothers. Cathy Downs has a prominent
supporting role. High Lonesome
(the title refers to a region of Texas), one of the early so-called
psychological westerns, is a tale of a young drifter suspected of
several murders, but who maintains his innocence. Unfortunately for
him, those he describes as the real guilty ones seem to be two men
who have been dead for many years. John Barrymore Jr. (here billed
as John Drew Barrymore) stars with good support from John Archer
(father of actress Anne Archer) and Lois Butler. Beyond their
relaxed and thoughtful nature, both films have much in common
including themes of loners and strong independent women plus some
good location work on various ranches in Texas (the actual spreads
are listed in the opening credits to both films) and fine supporting
casts that include the likes of Chill Wills, Jack Elam, Clem Fuller,
and Frank Cordell.
VCI presents both films on DVD correctly framed in full screen. The
images, allowing for the fact that no particular restoration has
been done, look quite nice, having been derived from the 35mm
negatives. There are plenty of speckles and scratches and a few
instances of missing frames, but the colour fidelity is good
(slightly more vibrant in High Lonesome)
and the images look quite sharp for the most part. Some of the
night-time scenes look a little murky. The mono sound is clear on
both films, but no subtitles are offered for either. Supplements are
fairly similar on both discs. Each offers a half-hour episode of
Stories of the Century - a
modestly entertaining (though rather fanciful - see the story of
Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid over 20 years reduced to 25
minutes in one of the episodes) western TV series produced by
Republic in the early 1950s, biographies of cast and crew, and photo
galleries. Recommended.
Bonanza Town (1951)
(released on DVD by Columbia on April 5th, 2005)
In a past review column, I had some uncomplimentary things to say
about the later Durango Kid westerns, not to mention the
questionable value to consumers of packaging them as stand-alone
titles at full price. I guess Columbia didn't take my comments to
heart (what a surprise!) for here we are again with much the same
situation for Bonanza Town.
Charles Starrett is back as the Durango Kid, with Smiley Burnette
along as his sidekick. This time, the story has to do with
recovering $30,000 stolen in a holdup for the Treasury Department.
The thief turns out to be an old nemesis of the Durango Kid, Henry
Hardison, who is now controlling a lawless town with the help of
local town boss Krag Boseman and a corrupt judge.
|
|
Most
of the later Durango Kid westerns were full of stock footage,
recycled casts, and perfunctory action. In their final years
(1952 saw the last one issued), filming was done in as little as
three days. Bonanza Town
is a particularly striking example of all the cost cutting, for
it lifts a couple of dozen minutes out of a previous Durango Kid
outing (West of Dodge City)
and drops them into the new film in the form of a flashback with
some framing narration by Starrett. There are a lot of welcome
familiar western players in this film, but most of them are from
the 1947 footage and uncredited here (George Chesebro, Bud
Osborne, Stanford Jolley, Bob Wilke, Marshall Reed). Cast
members of the new footage are not particularly inspiring, aside
from the reliable Myron Healey, and presumably to cut costs
further, director Fred Sears was pressed in service playing
chief villain Hardison.
|
|
I
guess the only reason this particular Durango Kid title is out on
DVD is because it was previously issued on VHS and Columbia couldn't
be bothered to give any new thought to a good marketing strategy for
the series on DVD. That's a shame, for the film looks great - a nice
crisp transfer (correctly presented full frame) with some slight
grain and very minor speckling. The mono sound is quite adequate,
but there are no sub-titles. The only supplements are a montage of
scenes from Columbia westerns and trailers for Silverado
and The Professionals.
The Old West (1952)
Blue Canadian Rockies
(1952)
Wagon Team (1952)
(released on DVD by Image on January 4th, April 5th, and April
19th, 2005 respectively)
Image has released three more Gene Autry westerns on DVD over the
past few months. All are from 1952, the second last year of Autry's
Columbia period and offer much the same blend of songs, mild action,
simple stories, and Gene's amiable but somewhat wooden acting style.
These are for Gene Autry fans only, as they pale in comparison to
the better B westerns of earlier years.
|
|
In
The Old West, Gene intervenes
in a dispute between competing stagecoach lines and manages to
subdue bad guy Doc Lockwood (Lyle Talbot) despite suffering a
serious gunshot wound. Gail Davis appears as the owner of the line
for which Gene is working and Pat Buttram provides comic relief.
Blue Canadian Rockies finds
Gene trying to sort out an attempted murder at an operation trying
to make a go of a dude ranch and game preserve in the midst of
logging country. Gail Davis and Pat Buttram once again co-star,
while veteran Tom London has an important role. In Wagon
Team, Gene attempts to track down a young army-payroll
thief, but he has competition from a gang of robbers who want the
payroll themselves. Former child star Dick Jones plays the young
thief while Gail Davis and Pat Buttram appear once again. The Cass
County Boys also provide musical support in both of the latter
films. There is little to choose between the three films in terms of
overall entertainment value. If it's the musical content that you
appreciate best in the Autry films, all fill the bill. If it's
western action that you prefer, these are all light in that respect,
both in terms of quantity and style of execution.
As with all of the Autry films released by Image so far, the black
and white source material has been restored and the DVD images
(presented correctly full frame) are quite pleasing. Along with the
Hopalong Cassidy films, they're generally the best-looking of any B
westerns available on DVD. The transfers provide bright, clean, and
quite crisp images with good shadow detail and no edge effects. The
Old West is perhaps slightly softer-looking than the
other two. The mono sound is clear with negligible hiss. There are
no sub-titles. Each disc has the usual set of supplements - the
conversations between Gene and Pat Buttram recorded for use on the
Melody Ranch Theater program
that aired the films on television, production and publicity stills
and poster art, excerpts from the original Melody Ranch radio show,
press kit material, and the original theatrical trailer. Recommended
for Gene Autry fans.
The Violent Men
(1955)
(released on DVD by Columbia on April 5th, 2005)
Columbia has released a whole slew of westerns new to DVD this
month and this is the best of them. Filmed in the unforgettable Lone
Pine area of California, The Violent Men
has all the elements of a top-notch western - a first-rate cast,
beautiful photography, a classic story, plenty of action, and a lush
score to back it all up. Ex-Confederate soldier John Parrish, after
a lengthy recovery from wounds suffered during the Civil War, plans
to sell his ranch and move east to get married. The prospective
purchaser is the vast Anchor Ranch, Parrish's neighbor and an outfit
intent on gaining control of the whole valley. An insultingly low
offer from Anchor's owner, the crippled Lee Wilkison, followed by
the brutal murder of one of Parrish's men, leads Parrish to rethink
his plans. As Parrish considers ways to retaliate, Wilkison has his
own difficulties. His wife Martha secretly despises her husband and
plans to take over Anchor along with Wilkison's younger brother
Cole. An explosive range war breaks out leading to double-dealing
and murder.
|
|
Glenn
Ford is top-billed as Parrish and he is every inch the western
loner - a man somewhat out of place, but ultimately more than
able to stand his ground. By 1955, Ford had a lengthy career
behind him with a steady stream of western roles sprinkled
through it. He looks the part and conveys an undercurrent of
toughness that although it makes the audience know what's
coming, provides a delicious sense of anticipation. Arrayed
against him is a tremendous trio of western archetypes - the
greedy but physically-flawed rancher given a grand portrayal by
Edward G. Robinson (even if Robinson would later say he was less
than overwhelmed by the role); the outwardly accommodating and
loving but secretly plotting wife (who else but Barbara
Stanwyck); and the handsome, over-confident and sneering younger
brother here embodied by Brian Keith. In keeping with the
film's very traditional story, the film was shot, as previously
mentioned, in one of the genre's most famous locations - Lone
Pine, with its famous Alabama Hills and the snow-capped Sierra
Nevadas in the distance. Interestingly, the Anchor Ranch in the
film reflects the existence of a real Anchor Ranch that was
located in the Lone Pine Valley. The whole setting is used to
great pictorial advantage by director Rudolph Maté,
enhanced by the use of Technicolor and CinemaScope. It frames
many of the film's scenes beautifully from simple ones of riders
crossing the valley to action sequences including the burning of
the ranch-houses and the ambushing of the Anchor riders among
the rocks near Parrish's ranch. A lush score that incorporates
some traditional western themes and that could be by no other
than Max Steiner provides a very pleasing sonic background to
the show.
|
|
Columbia
presents the film on DVD in a 2.55:1 anamorphic transfer (despite
ambiguous packaging that states "2.55:1 full screen") that
is very pleasing. There are some signs of wear on the print, but the
image is quite sharp with very good contrast and colour fidelity.
There are no edge effects. The Dolby Digital 3.0 stereo score offers
some nice separation effects and is complimentary to Steiner's
score. Supplements are limited to a two-minute montage of scenes
from various Columbia westerns and trailers for Silverado
and The Professionals. Highly
recommended.
Three Violent People
(1957)
(released on DVD by Paramount on April 19th, 2005)
Charlton Heston played in a number of westerns during his career
and for the most part, his efforts provided successful
entertainments. Arrowhead,
The Big Country, and Will
Penny are several good examples. Three
Violent People (working title, Maverick) proved to be one
of the less interesting ones. Filmed on location in Arizona though
set in Texas, Heston plays Civil War veteran Colt Saunders who
returns to his ranch picking up new bride Lorna (Anne Baxter) along
the way. Once there, he is faced with preventing the corrupt
provisional government from attempting to take over his ranch.
Initially, Saunders has the support of his brother (Tom Tryon),
wife, and a loyal band of Vaqueros (headed by Gilbert Roland) who
have helped manage the Saunders ranch for years. Eventually,
however, a wedge is driven between them and Colt due to his
intransigent attitudes, leaving the field wide open for the
provisional government's crooked representatives to pounce.
|
|
The
story here is a pretty thin one that isn't particularly
enlivened by any substantially inspiring work from director
Rudolph Maté - the film's main action sequences are
pretty standard fare aside from the intriguing substitution of a
whisky decanter for an hourglass during one impending gun duel.
Thus left to themselves, the actors make a valiant effort, but
only Heston offers any reason to see the film. In his hands, the
standard "man's gotta do what a man's gotta do" role
actually takes on some life beyond the cliché. Baxter's
efforts seem a little overwrought while Tryon's work is
indistinguishable from that of a hundred other young actors in
similar western roles. Nor do the bad guys cause any great
excitement. Bruce Bennett, Forrest Tucker, and Barton MacLane
(who just seems to disappear from the film) are a bland bunch
(despite some bluster from MacLane - an actor who never spoke
when shouting would do) that never gives the slightest hint of
ever being able to best Heston's character.
|
|
Paramount's
1.85:1 anamorphic presentation of the VistaVision film is its usual
competent effort. The image looks crisp and clear with
accurate-looking colour. There are no edge effects and source
material defects (scratches, speckles) are minimal. The mono sound
is undistinguished. English subtitles are provided, but there are
typically for Paramount no supplements.
Good Day for a Hanging
(1958)
(released on DVD by Columbia on April 5th, 2005)
After a few westerns early in his career (The
Texas Rangers [1936], Rangers
of Fortune 1940]), Fred MacMurray hit the saddle again in
earnest in the mid-1950s like many of his contemporary male stars.
MacMurray seemed like the least likely of that bunch to make an
effective western player, but his efforts usually turned out quite
well, focusing as they did on modest character studies rather than
full-blown western spectacles. Good Day
for a Hanging is a fine example. In it, MacMurray plays
former marshal Ben Cutler who finds himself part of a posse pursuing
a gang who have just robbed the town bank. Ben witnesses one of the
gang, Eddie "The Kid" Campbell - a youngster whom his
daughter has known growing up - shoot and kill town marshal Hiram
Cain. Eddie is captured and tried for Cain's murder, but his lawyer
is able to create doubt as to Eddie's guilt in all the members of
the posse except for Ben Cutler. His testimony results in Eddie's
conviction and subsequent sentencing to be hanged. By now Ben has
agreed to serve as interim marshal and the task falls to him to
carry out the execution. But what seemed like a straight-forward
affair soon becomes clouded, isolating Ben from the rest of the
townspeople.
|
|
The
film, with a nod to some aspects of High
Noon, is an engrossing little character study of
human nature and group dynamics, with the character of Ben
Cutler being plausibly developed by the script and acted in a
nicely understated fashion by MacMurray. The changing
relationship between Ben Cutler and the rest of the town feels
real and progresses to the point where one anticipates what is
likely to be a very ambivalent ending. It is at this point that
the film falters slightly, as it goes for the more conventional
western ending. Still the overall impact is positive and well
worth a look. Robert Vaughan makes a good impression playing the
Kid, while western aficionados will be pleased to see the likes
of James Drury, Denver Pyle, Emile Meyer, Harry Lauter, and Tom
London among the supporting cast.
|
|
Columbia
has released the film with a 1.85:1 anamorphic transfer, but the
Columbia Color has not aged well. The image lacks vibrancy and
frequently seems faded. A fair amount of film grain is in evidence
as are speckles and some scratches, adding in this case to the
film's rather lacklustre look. The mono sound is workmanlike,
neither adding nor subtracting from the experience. English and
Japanese subtitles are provided. Supplements consist of a montage of
scenes from various Columbia westerns and trailers for Silverado
and The Professionals.
Recommended as a rental.
Bad Girls (1994)
(released on DVD by Fox on February 1st, 2005)
The idea of a western film centered around four women would be a
pretty good one if presented realistically. Unfortunately, Bad
Girls is a piece of fluff that leans more to the nature
of an old B western with a well-dressed hero than the grit of an
Unforgiven to whose popularity
this 1994 film undoubtedly owes its existence. The only tip of the
hat to the more modern western is a rather blatant though modest
attempt to rip off the ending of The Wild
Bunch. Given all that, and in the right mood to be
entertained by fluff, Bad Girls
can be an amiable time passer just as some of the glossier B
westerns of the mid 1940s (such as some of the Roy Rogers musical
extravaganzas) could be.
|
|
The
film went through a couple of directors and several leads before
the final cast of Madeleine Stowe, Drew Barrymore, Andie
MacDowell, and Mary Stuart Masterson was settled on. The four
play prostitutes on the run after one of them kills a man.
Chased by Pinkerton detectives, they run astray of a gang of
ruthless outlaws with which one of the women (Stowe) used to
ride. This jeopardizes a plan they have to homestead in Oregon.
After Stowe's character is brutalized by the gang leader, she is
helped by a mysterious young stranger, but he is later captured
by the gang himself, leading to a climactic shootout. The film
offers a reasonable amount of action (although it does miss an
opportunity to stage a train robbery, preferring only to show
the aftermath), but the plot seems cobbled together with little
realistic explanation for the women's abilities, which are made
to seem considerable both with horses and with guns. Aside from
Stowe who actually looks a little hot and bothered at times, the
leads generally never give the impression of being other than
movie stars playing at being cowboys. Among the supporting cast,
only veteran Robert Loggia in a somewhat curious role as one of
the outlaw gang is at all noticeable. Jerry Goldsmith does
provide some nice theme music for the film. Shooting was carried
out on location in Texas and Sonora, California.
|
|
Fox's
1.85:1 anamorphic transfer is very nice. It provides a generally
crisp transfer characterized by vibrant colour and realistic flesh
tones. There is a minor hint of edge effects from time to time, but
the overall impact is very favourable. A full frame transfer is also
included on the flip side of the disc. The Dolby Digital 5.1
surround track is very pleasing. It provides effective use of the
surrounds and good front separation. Action sequences have good
sonic presence without being exaggerated. French and Spanish stereo
tracks as well as English and Spanish subtitles are provided. The
only supplements are two trailers, although the release is billed as
an extended cut that apparently adds a minute or so to the
theatrical cut.
Deadwood: The Complete First
Season (2004)
(released on DVD by HBO on February 8th, 2005)
With the western genre in the doldrums, it took some nerve for HBO
to go ahead with a new western series called Deadwood.
It was a gamble that paid off though, as the series scored heavily
with viewers and brought considerable awards attention from the
Emmys and Golden Globes, among others. The series documents events
in the wide-open frontier town of Deadwood, South Dakota in the days
of the Black Hills gold strike soon after Custer's last stand at
Little Big Horn. It's almost impossible to do justice to the story
line in a few sentences here, so intricate and layered is it. The
first season's twelve episodes follow the fortunes of a disparate
group of characters including the legendary Wild Bill Hickok and
Calamity Jane. But this is no standard western telling of the lives
of those characters. They are simply two of an amazing group of
outlaws, settlers, prospectors, ex-lawmen, whores, businessmen good
and bad who inhabit Deadwood in those early days. At the centre of
it all is saloon owner Al Swearengen (Ian McShane) who sees the
possibility of a profit in every situation and acts as the de facto
town boss and magnet for the town's illegal and immoral activities.
On the opposite side of the fence are former lawman Seth Bullock
(Timothy Olyphant) and Hickok (Keith Carradine). Somewhere in
between are the likes of Doc Cochran (Brad Dourif), Seth's partner
Sol Star (John Hawkes), hotelier E.B. Farnum (William Sanderson),
laudanum addict Alma Garret (Molly Parker), Calamity Jane (Robin
Weigert), and many others who come and go. Each character is
distinct and richly drawn in episodes that vary from action-filled
to intricately-drawn character studies. It may take you an episode
or two to get into the series, but once in, you're hooked.
|
|
Deadwood
was created by David Milch who acts as both executive producer
and writer and whose most familiar previous credit was NYPD
Blue for which he was also creator and executive
producer. His evocation of time and place is one of the series'
chief virtues. It feels real; with its subdued colour, it looks
real; and it sounds real (if at times painfully so, with its
blend of high-toned precise English and then gutter-level
profanity). The latter deserves some comment, for it is the
program's high level of profanity that has occasioned the most
reaction. It seems likely that the raw nature of Deadwood's then
state of development and its male-dominated population would
result in the level of swearing that the series depicts. Whether
the nature of the profanity is accurate or not (it slants
towards current-day usage as opposed to what would likely have
been a more religion-based profanity over a century ago), the
fact of its ubiquitousness in such an environment and time seems
right and adds to the feeling of authenticity. As to the look of
Deadwood in 1876, I have no idea as to its accuracy, but again
the general air of chaos and unkemptness strikes the right
chord.
|
|
The
episodes benefit from a very skilled cast each of whom seem deeply
immersed in their characters. Of course, the excellent writing is a
big contributor, but the actors all make the most of the material.
Every one seems like a real, distinct individual and all have at
times in the various media coverage of the series been duly
recognized. I suspect that every viewer will have their personal
favourite, but it seems clear that there is virtually universal
approval of the work of Ian McShane as Swearengen. I certainly
concur. It's a richly drawn evocation of a complex character. For
me, Keith Carradine and Timothy Olyphant also score heavily, and I
always enjoy Powers Boothe's efforts (even if a lesser one here).
Warner Bros. has issued the complete first season in a six-disc box
set. The twelve episodes are contained on the first five discs
(either two or three episodes per disc) while the last disc is
reserved for the bulk of the supplementary features. The episodes
are presented in 1.78:1 anamorphic transfers that look impressive.
The image is sharp and colour fidelity is very good (although
colours are subdued reflecting the way the material was shot). Image
detail is very good, although there is an excessive loss of detail
in a few dark scenes. A Dolby Digital 5.1 sound track provides a
strong sound stage across the fronts, but there is but infrequent
use of the surrounds. Dolby 2.0 tracks are also provided in English,
French, and Spanish as are corresponding sub-titles. The supplements
include audio commentaries on four episodes (David Milch on episode
1: Deadwood; Molly Parker and
Keith Carradine on episode 4: Here Was a
Man; Brad Dourif and Robin Weigert on episode 5: The
Trial of Jack McCall; and Ian McShane and Timothy
Olyphant on episode 12: Sold Under Sin).
None are startling commentaries, but all are informative and
reasonably diverting, the one with Dourif and Weigert probably being
the best of the bunch. The rest of the supplements consist of four
featurettes. Two of them (comprising almost an hour of material)
feature Carradine and Milch in conversation on the language used in
the series (The New Language of the Old
West) and on the blending of historical and fictional
characters (An Imaginative Reality).
The third one talks about the real town of Deadwood and its history,
while the fourth is a fairly standard making-of effort. All four are
worth your time. Highly recommended.
Forthcoming Westerns on DVD
I've created
a
table of upcoming western films on DVD. This is partially a
subset of the classic film database, but in the spirit of this
column includes all westerns, not just those originally released
prior to about 1970. The next few months include quite a number of
westerns among the various DVD releases on tap, as traditionally the
spring months are the most popular for western releases. There is
another lesser bump in mid-autumn. Some of the highlights are
summarized below. For the complete listing, please
click
here.
Looking over the line-up for the April-to-June period, virtually
all the studios are active in western releases. Warner Bros. has
some Errol Flynn and John Wayne efforts, as well as several
more-recent Turner cable westerns. Columbia has two cycles of
releases, a large one in early April that includes a lot of 1940s
and 1950s titles (e.g. Desperadoes,
Lust for Gold, Jubal,
The Violent Men) and a smaller
one in late May that includes an early Tim McCoy outing. Fox pumps
out seven titles in late May featuring the likes of Henry Fonda,
Spencer Tracy, Gregory Peck, and Barbara Stanwyck among others. In
mid May, MGM has five titles mainly from the 1960s (highlighted by
Hour of the Gun) while
Paramount sprinkles titles throughout April, May, and June (Johnny
Reno, Waterhole #3,
The Reivers, Three
Violent People, Branded,
etc.). Universal, which usually comes through with a slew of
westerns at this time of year, has so far only announced The
Appaloosa (as part of a Brando set).
On the horizon are several other highly anticipated releases: a
restored version of Major Dundee
from Columbia originally expected May 31st, but now apparently
delayed until August 30th; new SEs of A
Fistful of Dollars and For a
Few Dollars More (although actual timing is an issue what
with the acquisition of MGM by Sony); and several John Wayne
westerns (e.g. Hondo, McClintock!
- originally produced by Wayne's company Batjac) that were acquired
by Paramount for DVD release beginning later this year.
For B western and serial fans, the usual state of affairs seems
likely to persist. Many such films are in the public domain so that
whenever versions are released, the results are usually less than
ideal as the source material has normally not been restored. Still,
VCI normally puts out a good product and so expectations for three
1930s serials (including two with Johnny Mack Brown) on May 31st are
promising. Among the films of the major B western stars, only those
of Gene Autry and Hopalong Cassidy have received restoration
efforts. Image has systematically been releasing the former and two
titles are planned for mid April (Blue
Canadian Rockies, Wagon Team).
There are currently no further Cassidy westerns announced from
Platinum who have handled the most recent quality releases. A June
7th release of a Cassidy triple bill from Falcon Picture Group
should probably be avoided. There are plenty of other B westerns
coming out from Alpha and other public domain specialists including
numerous independent outfits that issue DVD-R versions, but only
Alpha seems to make its plans readily available so its releases are
included in the database. In all such cases, it's always a case of
buyer beware. Some titles are very good; some are very bad. Word-of
mouth is your best bet on such sources.
Well, that should keep you western addicts going for a little
while. There's lots of good fare coming up and I look forward to
returning with more reviews and western DVD information later this
spring. See yuh then, pardners!
Barrie Maxwell
barriemaxwell@thedigitalbits.com |
Barrie
Maxwell - Main Page |
|