Site created 12/15/97. |
|
review added: 5/9/01
Superman II
1980 (2001) - Warner Bros.
review by Bill Hunt,
editor of The Digital Bits
|
Film
Rating: B-
Disc Ratings (Video/Audio/Extras):
B-/C+/D+
Specs and Features
127 mins, PG, letterboxed widescreen (2.35:1), 16x9 enhanced,
single-sided, RSDL dual-layered (layer switch at ??), Snapper case
packaging, cast & crew bios, theatrical trailer, film-themed
menu screens with music, scene access (37 chapters), languages:
English (DD 2.0) & French (1.0 mono), subtitles: English,
French, Spanish & Portuguese, Closed Captioned
|
"You will kneel
before Zod!!"
Superman II is one of those "if
only" movies. If only Alexander and Ilya Salkind had allowed
director Richard Donner back to finish it. If only fill-in director
Richard Lester had paid more attention to detail and to the tone of
what had been shot before him. If only Warner had made this a
special edition DVD. Okay... I'm getting ahead of myself.
Filmed mostly at the same time as the original Superman:
The Movie, this first sequel actually takes up a story
thread left hanging (intentionally) at the beginning of the first
film. Remember Ursa, Non and General Zod (Sarah Douglas, Jack
O'Halloran and Terence Stamp), the Kryptonian baddies sentenced to
eternity in the Phantom Zone by Jor-El? Well... when a terrorist
plot to blow up the Eiffel Tower with an H-bomb is foiled by
Superman (Christopher Reeve), he sends the bomb careening off into
deep space just in time. But the blast from the explosion shatters
the Phantom Zone, releasing the bad guys and allowing them to engage
in a reign of terror back on Earth. And unfortunately, Superman has
just decided to give up his super powers to live as a mere mortal
with his true love, Lois Lane (Margot Kidder). Can Superman get his
powers back in time to save the day, or will General Zod bring the
people of Earth to their knees? I'm sure you can guess the answer to
that question - Truth, Justice and the American way never seem to
fail on the big screen. But before we get to see that obligatory
shot of Superman smiling at the camera and flying off into the
sunset, he'll have to face off against the villains in a titanic
battle of super might and somewhat dated special effects.
The biggest problem with Superman II,
is that it's terribly uneven. All of the footage shot by Donner is
pretty good, and very much follows the tone of the original film.
But when Richard Lester steps in, all we get are wooden performances
from the cast and cheese, cheese, cheese. What's worse, Lester
abandoned some cool, already-filmed scenes that would really have
added to the story, including one in which Jor-El (played by Marlon
Brando) sacrifices himself to restore his son's powers. Still, the
film isn't nearly as bad as you might expect. In fact, it's pretty
okay. I remember really loving it as a kid. It's just that when you
realize what this film could have been, you have to cringe.
The same can also be said for Warner's new DVD. The film is
presented in anamorphic widescreen, but it's very much lacking
compared to the original film on DVD. The print isn't in the best of
shape, and is very soft looking at times. Color is okay, but
contrast is somewhat less than desirable. Worse yet, the audio is
only available in Dolby Digital 2.0 surround. A 5.1 remix would have
really kicked things up a few notches.
And even worse than that, all you get in terms of extras are a
paltry list of cast and crew bios and the film's theatrical trailer
(at least it's also anamorphic). While some of this film's complex
history is covered in the documentaries on the
Superman:
The Movie DVD, this disc really should have had a more
in-depth look at the controversies and problems surrounding the
film. And what about all that deleted footage? ABC has run Superman
II on network TV, featuring a cut that's more than 17
minutes longer than what we get here! There are numerous deleted
scenes (click
here for a detailed list via IMDB.com), and none of them have
found their way onto this DVD. If only...
Superman II is an adequate
sequel to the original film, and it's far better than the two films
in the series that follow. But you just can't help wondering what
might have been, and that definitely goes for this new DVD. I
sincerely hope Warner will revisit this title at some point in the
future as a special edition, because (flawed though it may be) it
definitely deserves better treatment. In any case, if you're a fan,
Superman II is worth having on
disc. Otherwise, skip it and pick up Superman:
The Movie on DVD instead. Trust me... you'll be much
happier with that disc than this one.
Bill Hunt
billhunt@thedigitalbits.com |
Superman II
The Complete Superman Collection
|
|