Site created 12/15/97. |
|
review added: 5/2/00
Young Frankenstein
Special
Edition - 1974 (1989/1999) - 20th Century Fox
review by Greg Suarez of
The Digital Bits
Re-release DVD
Cover
Original DVD Cover |
Film
Rating: A
Disc Ratings (Video/Audio/Extras):
B-/D+/A
Specs and Features
106 mins, PG, letterboxed widescreen (1.85:1), single-sided,
dual-layered (no layer switch), Amaray keep case packaging,
commentary by director/co-writer Mel Brooks, production featurette
Making FrankenSense of Young Frankenstein,
7 deleted scenes, outtakes/bloopers, Mexican interviews, 5
theatrical trailers, 3 TV spots, production photos, film-themed menu
screens, scene access (28 chapters), languages: English, French, and
Spanish (DD Mono), subtitles: English, Closed Captioned |
"I am Frau
Bluecher."
The ingredients for a successful comedy go way beyond the script.
Directing and acting have a great deal to do with a winning film,
and Young Frankenstein has it
all. The brilliant script by Mel Brooks and Gene Wilder has just the
right amount of satire, silliness, and wit to make this film an
enduring comedy classic. The casting is dead-on perfect, and the
acting never seems phony and wooden like that of so many other
comedies.
Dr. Frederick Frankenstein (pronounced "Fronckensteen",
played by Gene Wilder) is the great grandson of the infamous Victor
Frankenstein, the man that went into graveyards, dug up freshly
buried corpses, and transformed dead components into
"yes,
yes - we all know what he did." Anyway, the young Dr.
Frankenstein (pronounced "Fronckensteen") inherits his
great grandfathers castle in Europe, and decides to travel
there to recreate the work of his mad relative (even though he has
spent his life trying to escape the family reputation). The young
doctor recruits the services of the humorous hunchback Igor
(pronounced "Eye-gor", played by Marty Feldman) and the
bueatiful Inga (Teri Garr) to assist him in his quest to reanimate
the dead. Dr. Frankenstein (remember, its pronounced "Fronckensteen")
creates a monster (played by Peter Boyle) that manages to escape and
strike fear into the hearts of the townsfolk. The doctor must
convince everyone that his creation is not evil and prove that he
had the best intentions.
The story of Young Frankenstein
follows the basic plot structure of Mary Shelleys original
novel fairly accurately, with Brooks and Wilder manipulating the
story and introducing new characters so effectively, that you
quickly stop comparing the film to other serious adaptations of the
novel and simply sit back and enjoy the humor. The casting of this
film is one of its strongest points. Gene Wilder plays the role of
the mad doctor so well that the line between a serious performance
and a comedic performance becomes blurry. Wilder seems to play the
role naturally and provides an unexpected emotional energy. Marty
Feldman absolutely steals this film, as the funnyman to Wilders
straight arrow. Wilder does a great job of setting up a lot of jokes
for Feldman, and Feldman picks them up and takes off running. His
Igor is a loveable little man that can always find a bit of humor in
any situation (along with a few brains).
The scene from Young Frankenstein
that will forever stick out in my mind is, of course, Gene Hackmans
cameo as the lonely blind man (chapter 18). While the monster is
roaming around the countryside, he happens upon a small cottage
inhabited by a lonely, blind hermit desperate for companionship.
Hackmans performance as this overzealous hermit makes for some
of the funniest moments ever captured on film - they're worth the
price of this disc all by itself.
The DVD presentation of Young
Frankenstein is, unfortunately, non-anamorphic widescreen
(framed at 1.85:1). The black and white picture is actually pretty
good, with a nice gray scale and solid blacks. As is the nature of
many non-anamorphic transfers however, there is noticeable
compression artifacting, jagged edges, and an overall soft quality
to the picture that detracts from fine picture detail. The monaural
soundtrack is edgy and thin. Fidelity is harsh, and everything from
vocals to sound effects sounds too forward. Some could argue that
the harsh, dated characteristic of the soundtrack adds an element of
nostalgia to the movie (paralleling it to the famous 1931 Universal
Pictures version of Frankenstein),
but the soundtrack does have fidelity problems. While this movie
does not command a powerhouse 5.1 remix, the main musical theme by
John Morris is quite beautiful, and I would like to have heard a
more graceful delivery.
If the audio and video on this DVD isn't perfect, the quantity and
quality of the supplements more than make up for it. This is a
full-fledged special edition of Young
Frankenstein, offering a lot in the way of meaningful
extras (note that there was an almost identical release of this disc
in 1998, differing only in the cover art on the box - see above).
The commentary by Mel Brooks is more an exercise in nostalgia, and
he manages to mention the names of almost everyone associated with
the movie. But the track is still worth listening to because it is
relatively informative, and Mr. Brooks seems like a very kind and
humble man who really enjoys what he does. The documentary
Making FrankenSense of Young Frankenstein
is also worth checking out. There are interesting interviews by
members of the cast and crew, and it gives fans of this movie great
insight into what went into its creation. Also available here are a
bevy of deleted scenes, some of which are okay and some of which
were thankfully excised from the final cut. The Mexican TV interview
is a very unique feature that makes for a curious addition to the
mix. While a little unusual to those used to the standard fare of
DVD supplements, it's interesting to view and provides a break from
the norm. There are also a number of TV spots and different
theatrical trailers. Finally, there are outtakes and bloopers which
are very funny and provide a great capstone to the comprehensive
offering of supplements found on this disc.
Young Frankenstein has
entertained all ages for the last quarter century, and remains
required viewing for comedy lovers everywhere. The script is
wonderfully zany and the casting is superb. While the video is
acceptable and the audio is terrible, there are a plethora of
wonderful supplements that will make Mel Brooks fans very happy
little mad scientists. Don't miss it.
Wait! Where are you going? I was going to make espresso!
Greg Suarez
gregsuarez@thedigitalbits.com |
|
|