Site created 12/15/97. |
|
review added: 6/24/99
The Samurai
Trilogy
reviews by Todd Doogan,
special to The Digital Bits
|
Samurai
I: Musashi Miyamoto
1954 (1998) Toho Company Ltd. (Criterion)
Film Rating: A
Disc Ratings (Video/Audio/Extras): B+/B+/
C
Specs and Features:
93 mins, NR, full frame (1.33:1), single-sided, single-layer,
Amaray keep case packaging, theatrical trailer, film-themed menu
screens, scene access (34 chapters), languages: Japanese (DD mono),
subtitles: English
|
|
Samurai
II: Duel at Ichijoji Temple
1955 (1998) Toho Company Ltd. (Criterion)
Film Rating: A
Disc Ratings (Video/Audio/Extras): B+/
B+/C
Specs and Features:
103 mins, NR, full frame (1.33:1), single-sided, single-layer,
Amaray keep case packaging, theatrical trailer, film-themed menu
screens, scene access (35 chapters), languages: Japanese (DD mono),
subtitles: English
|
|
Samurai
III: Duel at Ganryu Island
1956 (1998) Toho Company Ltd. (Criterion)
Film Rating: A
Disc Ratings (Video/Audio/Extras): B+/
B+/ C
Specs and Features:
104 mins, NR, full frame (1.33:1), single-sided, single-layer,
Amaray keep case packaging, theatrical trailer, film-themed menu
screens, scene access (38 chapters), languages: Japanese (DD mono),
subtitles: English |
Ah, samurai films. In
my heart of hearts, there is nothing better than a samurai film.
When I was a kid, I'd talk all my friends out of being cops and
robbers, cowboys and Indians, or superheroes, and into acting like
samurai warriors. We'd get sticks and have sword fights, dress in
full black, and run around the woods hunting each other down like
dogs. I had a pretty good childhood.
My first experience with samurai films was with Star
Wars. I didn't quite grasp just how much Star
Wars was like a samurai film when I was a kid, but
looking back on it, I'd have to say that it's a fair summation --
even more so with the new Episode I.
Anyway, I started to dig the whole honorable sword fight thing, and
I'd go to my local video store with my parents, and ask for sword
fight movies. I was given Seven Samurai
by the local video clerk, and I loved it. In fact, I couldn't stop
watching it. The video store clerk ended up giving me a copy on my
birthday, because I rented it so much. He also turned me onto a
whole bunch of other Kurosawa samurai films: Yojimbo,
The Hidden Fortress (the film
upon which Star Wars is based,
and that even then, made me go hmmm...) and Sanjuro.
Yeah, I was a weird kid.
My father didn't quite know what to think of me watching movies I
had to read. One time, after he watched Yojimbo
with me, he went out and rented Fistful
Of Dollars for me, and from that point on, I considered
samurai films to be cowboy movies in disguise. Now I'm really into
spaghetti westerns as well. My mother didn't care, as long as I
wasn't running the streets and doing drugs. The Kurosawa samurai
films were the only ones available to me as a kid, but as I grew
older, and my passion for the genre grew with me, I sought more and
more titles. Over the years, I've dug up The
Sleepy Eyes Of Death, Lone
Wolf and Cub, and the Zatoichi
series, and I still watch samurai films with the same child-like
passion.
That's why it's my great pleasure to turn you on to a series of
films that are very dear to me, The
Samurai Trilogy. Except for the fact that you have to "read"
them, The Samurai Trilogy is
very much like a series of American costume films. They are very
watchable, very understandable, and very entertaining. The films are
based on the book Musashi Miyamoto,
which has been called the Japanese Gone
With The Wind - a comparison that, although true based on
popularity and sheer scale, seems unfair, mainly because I'm not a
big fan of Gone With The Wind.
Musashi Miyamoto was a real historical person. He was a master
swordsman, philosopher, and painter. Miyamoto was a well regarded
man through his life, and after his death. Even today, many business
students follow his writings (most notably Gorin
No Sho - a.k.a. The Book of
the Five Rings). But so what? Do the films deliver? You
betcha.
The Samurai Trilogy isn't from
Kurosawa -- but that's okay. The director was Hiroshi Inagaki, who
went on direct two other samurai masterpieces, Chushingura
(1962) and Samurai Banners
(1969). The films follow Miyamoto from being a young ballsy kid, up
to his early retirement (which he eventually left to do battle once
more), all the way battling those who stand before him. The first of
the films starts with Miyamoto as a young man (then known as
Takezo), who goes off to fight in the Japanese civil war, around
1600. He survives his first battle, but he and his friend are both
hurt and tired, so they take up refuge with a woman and her
daughter, and things kind of start there for Takezo. You have to pay
attention, because virtually all of the characters introduced in the
first film will follow Takezo through the later films in various
ways. To go too much into story, would be a disservice to the films
themselves - they really should be watched by all fans of big epic
movie-making. Suffice it to say, Takezo goes from head strong young
man, to brute thug, to enlightened Buddhist, to an undefeated
warrior, and eventually to content farmer. It takes three films, and
a little over 5 hours to tell this story. And what a story.
The cast of characters are all intriguing and well drawn. From the
women who love him, the Buddhist priest who teaches him the road to
enlightenment, and his young student in the final film, you will
feel like you will know each and every one of them. Even though I
have never read the book these films were based on, the entire film
plays out like a beautiful novel. It also helps that Takezo is
played by Toshiro Mifune, one of my top three favorite actors of all
time (Robert Shaw and Chow Yun-Fat are my other two, if you care).
His acting is so good here -- he goes through such a range, it's a
marvel to behold. Mifune was just so damn good at what he did. God
bless him.
Of course, samurai films wouldn't be anything without sword fights,
and there are some great ones in this series. The first film has
plenty of battles, often with a great number of people involved in
each. The second film opens with a bang, as Takezo battles a warrior
armed with a chain and sickle, and it just gets better from there.
The series ends with a battle featuring Takezo, against his long
time fan and biggest rival, Sasaki Kojiro, on the beach of Ganryu, a
rivalry that grows out of the second film. The final battle, even if
it's not as elaborate as the others, is breathtaking, mainly because
it's the last one, and the angel of death hovers so close to our
main character.
I think The Samurai Trilogy
is a very important set of films, and they work so well on a great
many levels. I'd like to see more people fall in love with these
films. Hopefully, the samurai genre will be rejuvenated after that
Steven Spielberg guy makes Memoirs Of A
Geisha in 2000.
As they stand on DVD, the trilogy looks and sounds wonderful. I
guess you should keep in mind that these are old movies from another
land. The film quality differs from country to country, and as a
rule, Japan was pretty good when it came to storage. Too many pre-50
films have been lost, thanks to... well, we Americans. But since
The Samurai Trilogy was made
in the mid 50's, we're okay. The film stock is grainy and/or washed
out in parts, but overall it looks really good. They are in color,
and sometimes the color looks slightly off, but this is probably due
to the early color processes. I don't think any problem with the
film, is due to the transfer or restoration. For what these films
are, The Samurai Trilogy looks
great. The audio is in the original Japanese mono, and sounds fine -
no problems there. You can't get caught up with extras on a set of
films like this, so just getting a trailer is a plus. It's nice to
see how film trailers looked back then, and compared to early
Hollywood trailers, these Japanese trailers seem much more like our
modern day variety. All in all, Criterion gives us a neat package
with this trio of discs.
If you get the chance, take a road trip down the film history
highway, and check out some cool, early samurai flicks, outside of
the Kurosawa gallery. The Samurai Trilogy
is a good place to start. As I state above, if you don't mind
reading, these films are chock full of great actors, wonderful
storylines, and pack enough thrills to make a modern day filmmaker
wish he'd stayed in school -- or behind the video store counter.
Todd
Doogan
todddoogan@thedigitalbits.com
|
|
Samurai I: Musashi
Miyamoto
Samurai II: Duel at
Ichijoji Temple
Samurai III: Duel at
Ganryu Island
|
|