Site created 12/15/97. |
|
review added: 2/6/99
The X-Files: Fight
the Future
Dolby Digital (AC3) / DTS
comparison
1998 (1998) - 20th Century
Fox
review by Bill Hunt,
editor of The Digital Bits
|
Program
Rating: A-
The X-Files gives you shadow
conspiracies, deadly plagues, insidious plots, and good, motivated
action. The villains are as vile as they come, and our noble heroes
struggle through their darkest hour. Throw in a pair of black
helicopters, a UFO, and some particularly nasty little green men,
and what more could you want? Good stuff.
Disc Ratings (AC3 - Video/Audio): A/A
Disc Ratings (DTS - Video/Audio): A/A+
The letterboxed widescreen video is excellent on both releases. The
color is rich and full. The picture is a bit soft at times -
definitely more than you'd see on DVD. But the DVD is still a few
months away yet. The audio is also very good on both versions, with
good clarity and full, deep bass. The DTS version adds just that
extra measure of both.
Overall Rating (AC3/DTS): A/A+
A great flick, worthy of purchase in either sound format - neither
will fail to please. If you're a DVD-only household, hold out for
the 5" version, which comes out in late April. But if you're
laserdisc-capable, and you really dig this film, why wait? You'll be
very happy with either of these fine discs. |
Specs
and Features
Dolby Digital (AC3): 122 mins,
PG13, letterboxed widescreen (2.35:1), 2 discs (3 sides), 21
chapters, Sides 1 & 2 CLV (Extended Play), Side 3 CAV (Standard
Play), audio: English (DD 5.1 & matrixed PCM 2.0), Close
Captioned
DTS: 122 mins, PG13,
letterboxed widescreen (2.35:1), 2 discs (3 sides), 22 chapters,
Sides 1 & 2 CLV (Extended Play), Side 3 CAV (Standard Play),
audio: English (DTS 5.1 & analog 2.0), Close Captioned
Review
The Truth is Out There... on a laserdisc player near you. You don't
really have to know anything about The
X-Files to enjoy the film, but loyal TV viewers will
benefit from some additional context and back-story. That said,
newbies should have no problem here - the bad guys are clearly bad
guys, the good guys are engaging, and the plot's got plenty of
mystery and action. Intrepid FBI special agents Fox Mulder (David
Duchovny) and Dana Scully (Gillian Anderson) work just fine on the
larger canvas. I saw it in the theater with my wife and brother
(neither of whom are fans of the show), and both of them really
enjoyed the film.
The cinematography is really great - all the dark, dynamic imagery
we've come to expect from the show, looks great on the wide screen.
The effects are very good, until near the end, where a couple of
shots on the ice field don't quite measure up (you'll know what I
mean). But it still works pretty well. The film visits locations
unlike any seen in the show before. The acting is all first rate:
Martin Landau and Armin-Mueller Stahl, in particular, are fantastic
additions to the gallery of spooks and wierdos that populate the
X-Files mythology. We do get
to see a little more deeply into the lives of Mulder and Scully than
ever before, and the events of the film serve to deepen their
relationship, as well as their determination to seek the Truth. If
you go into this flick expecting to be blown away by an awesome
film, you'll be disappointed. On the other hand, if you go in
expecting a really big, grand two-hour episode of the series, you'll
really dig it. This isn't so much a criticism of the film, rather
it's more a testament to the terrific quality of the series week in
and week out. Can you tell I'm a big fan? Well I am.
The letterboxed widescreen video quality is very good on both
versions of the laserdisc. The image is a bit softer than I'm used
to on DVD, but once I made the adjustment, I was very happy - it's
very film-like in appearance. The color is rich and full, and the
flesh tones are accurate. The contrast is generally excellent, with
solid blacks and good shadow detail. And the transfer is also
excellent, with very little dust, film grain, or other unwanted
artifacts to be seen. Clearly, a pristine print was used. This is a
great laserdisc picture. I'm still bugged by having to swap the
discs (my only peeve with laserdisc), but it's still a great visual
experience.
The 5.1 audio was also pleasing on both versions. I found the
dynamic range to be generally excellent on the Dolby Digital (AC3)
version, with deep bass, and good spatial ambiance. There's good
directionality where appropriate, but nothing artificial sounding -
nothing gimmicky. The dialogue seems generally natural, and is well
spread over the front half of the sound field. All in all, a very
satisfying three-dimensional sound environment is created. The DTS
version adds a subtle measure of clarity to the sound experience,
and seems to have a slightly wider dynamic range. Certain low
frequency sounds were more audible on the DTS, and a small handful
of sounds that I didn't hear at all on the AC3 version were subtly
conveyed by the DTS track. The aggressive score, by series composer
Mark Snow, was nicely mixed with the sound effects and dialogue in
both versions, and definitely added impact to the visuals.
Both versions of this laserdisc include an introduction, with
comments by X-Files creator
Chris Carter, and actress Gillian Anderson. Both versions also have
additional minutes of an important scene added (which were not shown
in theaters), wherein we learn what happened to Mulder's sister
Samantha. For non-series regulars, Samantha's disappearance years
ago (which Mulder believes was an extraterrestrial abduction) is
what drives his life-long quest to uncover the Truth.
Bottom line
The X-Files: Fight the Future
was, for me, an entirely satisfying first trip to the big screen.
The film gives you everything you've come to expect from good X-Files
and more. And the film experience is definitely delivered by these
two laserdisc releases. If you've got DTS capability, go for that
version. Otherwise, you'll be very happy with the Dolby Digital
release. And you DVD fans hang in there... your version is just a
couple of months away. Trust No One.
Bill Hunt
billhunt@thedigitalbits.com |
|
|