Site
created 12/15/97.
|
page
created: 1/19/05
Back
to Part One
Barrie
Maxwell - Main Page
|
The
Best of 2004, Reviews and the Latest Classic Announcements
(continued)
Carrie (1952)
(released on DVD by Paramount on January 18th, 2005)
Director William Wyler is quite well represented on DVD, with Carrie
being the latest of his films to appear. Based on Theodore Dreiser's
"Sister Carrie", this 1952 film has nothing to do with
nuns or nurses as the original novel's title might suggest. (Nor, I
might add, does it have any connection to the later 1976 Sissy
Spacek film of the same title.) It is instead a turn of the century
drama about a young woman named Carrie who comes to Chicago from the
Missouri countryside to seek her fortune. She first falls in with a
glib salesman, but eventually develops a relationship with George
Hurstwood, a restaurant manager living comfortably but in a loveless
marriage. The two leave Chicago for a life together in New York, but
George has stolen money to support them and when he is found out,
the relationship soon fractures under the strain. Carrie leaves
Hurstwood to seek success on stage while Hurstwood finds himself on
the skids.
|
|
The
Dreiser novel had been published in 1900 and was considered
quite scandalous at the time due to its amoral characters.
William Wyler became interested in filming it in the 1940s but
could not get a script to his liking together until late 1949.
He then decided that the part of Hurstwood was ideal for
Laurence Olivier for whom he was willing to wait until he was
available. Elizabeth Taylor was Wyler's choice for Carrie, but
MGM would not loan her out and Wyler finally settled for
Jennifer Jones for whom David Selznick had been lobbying for
months. Although filming was done in late 1950 and Wyler
completed his final cut in early 1951, the film did not get
released by Paramount until mid-1952. The studio was concerned
about the atmosphere in the country due to the ongoing HUAC
hearings and feared the film's unattractive view of America
would not go down well. Paramount made cuts to the film and
finally released it with no fanfare. As a result, it did poorly
at the box-office and received little critical support. That's
unfortunate because although Jennifer Jones is rather passive as
Carrie, Laurence Olivier's work as Hurstwood is outstanding. His
transformation from successful businessman to flophouse denizen
is mesmerizing and alone makes the film well worth seeing. Eddie
Albert does some of his best work as the glib salesman.
|
|
Paramount
has released the film on DVD full frame in accord with the original
aspect ratio. The black and white image is in pretty decent shape
and is reasonably sharp. There is some grain and the odd vertical
scratch which gives the whole thing a somewhat gritty appearance,
but the transfer does provide a pretty film-like experience overall.
The mono sound is clear with just a hint of background hiss on
occasion. English subtitles are included. There are no supplements,
but the version of the film provided restores a flop-house scene
near the end. It was presumably one of the cuts made by the studio
prior to the original release. As a result, the film runs 121
minutes - three minutes longer than its previous home video
laserdisc release. Recommended.
Bob & Carol & Ted &
Alice (1969)
(released on DVD by Columbia on November 16th, 2004)
Here is one of the movies that helped define the late 1960s - a
satire that hits many of the buttons of the era, such as getting in
touch with one's feelings and exposing sexual hang-ups. Considered
somewhat risqué for its time, it now seems rather dated on
first analysis. Once you get used to the chains that used to adorn
men's necks and the ultra short skirts that were de rigueur for
women, however, it soon becomes apparent that there is still much in
the movie's main theme that hasn't changed in 35 years.
Understandably, the satire no longer has quite the bite it had, but
people are still trying to get in touch with their feelings and
although the orthodoxy may have been altered a little - now we
follow more holistic New Age therapies - the basic intent remains
much the same.
|
|
The
film focuses on Bob and Carol, a young couple who find their
approach to their relationship changed by a weekend retreat.
They try to introduce their new-found openness (which includes
accepting that each other have taken lovers on the side) to
their best friends Ted and Alice, but that repressed couple
finds Bob and Carol's new approach very difficult to deal with
at first. Ted and Alice's initially ambivalent feelings
eventually lead to a level of reluctant examination of their own
lives - one that finally reaches a climax during a weekend trip
with Bob and Carol to Las Vegas. Direction is by first-timer
Paul Mazursky, who also co-wrote the script. He draws marvelous
performances from all four leads - Robert Culp, Natalie Wood,
Elliott Gould, and Dyan Cannon. It's particularly pleasing to
see Gould deliver an effort relatively free of his usual
smirking mannerisms. The interaction between all four actors is
excellent, but each has a chance to shine on their own too. The
story is well-structured and builds to the climax effectively,
only to be let down somewhat by a silly ending.
|
|
Columbia
delivers a 1.85:1 anamorphic transfer that looks very good. The
image is crisp and colours look very natural. There are occasional
speckles and a few instances of mild grain, but I can't imagine
anyone finding much fault with this effort. The mono sound is in
good shape with no noticeable hiss or distortion. English and
Japanese sub-titles are provided. Supplements consist of a 17-minute
interview with Mazursky held at the Lee Strasberg Theater and Film
Institute in Hollywood, an audio commentary with Mazursky and the
three surviving stars, and several trailers. The interview is not
particularly informative, only occasionally telling anything useful
about the film, and being mainly a promotion for a new book of
Mazursky's. The audio commentary is one of the poorer ones, being
more an opportunity for self-congratulation than anything else. Of
the three trailers, only the one for Easy
Rider has any remote relevance to this disc. Still, the
film itself remains interesting and sporting a fine transfer,
warrants a recommendation.
The Latest New Classic
Announcements
The new year is off to a good start with worthy announcements from
many of the usual suspects. We go alphabetically by studio as usual,
and note that our Classic
Coming Attractions Database has been updated accordingly
(click the link to download it in zipped Word.doc format).
Alpha has 35 new releases set for February 22nd. Fourteen are TV
series including more Adventures of Robin
Hood and Sherlock Holmes.
There are also four volumes of something called Federal
Men. Among the features, we've got the usual mix of
mysteries, westerns, and serials (Fighting
Marines [1936] and The Phantom
Creeps [1939]) supplemented by four volumes of Laurel and
Hardy shorts apparently featuring each of the boys working on his
own prior to the teaming and the 1938 curiosity Terror
of Tiny Town featuring a cast entirely composed of little
people. Refer to the database for the full list of titles.
Anchor Bay has announced that its anticipated Ealing
War Collection (The Cruel
Sea/The Dam Busters/Went the Day Well/The Colditz Story/The Ship
That Died of Shame/Against the Wind) will be released on
March 22nd. Other titles planned by the company for a fall 2005
release are The Anniversary
(1968, with Bette Davis) and a spaghetti western The
Hellbenders (1967, with Joseph Cotten).
Columbia will release the 1949 15-chapter serial Batman
and Robin on March 22nd. Other titles in the works for
later in 2005 are The Violent Men
(1955, with Barbara Stanwyck and Edward G. Robinson, presented in
2.55:1 and presumably anamorphic), The
Stranger Wore a Gun (1953, with Randolph Scott), and two
Frank Capra films - American Madness
(1932, with Walter Huston) and The Bitter
Tea of General Yen (1933, with Barbara Stanwyck).
Criterion's March releases are as follows. On the 1st, we get Jean
Renoir's The River (1951). On
the 15th, there's a trio of films: Michelangelo Antoninoi's L'Eclisse
(1962), Volker Schlondorff's Young
Torless (1966), and Kihachi Okamoto's Sword
of Doom (1966). The 29th will bring Francois Truffaut's
Jules and Jim (1962).
Disney has four releases set for April 12th: The
Adventures of Bullwhip Griffin (1967, with Roddy
McDowell), The Barefoot Executive
(1971, with Kurt Russell), Lt. Robin
Crusoe (1967, with Dick Van Dyke), and The
Million Dollar Duck (1971, with Dean Jones).
Fox has delayed the previously scheduled Frank
Sinatra Collection (The
Detective/Lady in Cement/Tony Rome/Von Ryan's Express)
from February 1st to May 24th. New announcements include a Three
Stooges promotion scheduled for April 26th that includes three
discs: Soup to Nuts (1930),
Snow White and the Three Stooges
(1960), and Three Stooges in Color
(four public domain shorts [Disorder in
the Court, Malice in the
Palace, Sing a Song of Six
Pants, and Brideless Groom]
presumably colourized by Legend Films). In other Fox news, the
upcoming Leave Her to Heaven
disc includes several trailers for other Studio Classics titles, one
of which is In Old Chicago
(1938, with Tyrone Power) so that is presumably forthcoming in the
near future. The previously anticipated releases of Pinky
and Hush Hush Sweet Charlotte
no longer appear on Fox's schedule for the near future, but no
reason has been given.
In last month's summary of announcements, I mentioned Mackinac
Media's planned releases of Industrial
Strength Keaton, The Mack
Sennett Collection, and The
Mabel Normand Collection. The first will be a collection
of rare Keaton industrial films, commercials, outtakes, foreign
films, trailers, alternate versions, and various other rarities not
otherwise available. The other two will each be collections of
approximately 35 films of the respective artists' work.
Lion's Gate finally follows up its (Artisan's) first Laurel
and Hardy disc (from 2003) with Laurel
and Hardy: Volume Two, set for a March 15th release. It
will include the features Way Out West
(1937) and Block Heads (1938)
as well as the short Chickens Come Home
(1931). It's nice of Hallmark (who own the rights) to throw out
another bone to the boys' adherents in Region 1, but let's hope the
quality is better than the first. Not that it matters much; anyone
who really cares has already gotten the superior Region 2 releases.
MGM will have a busy April with a new SE of The
Graduate (1967, with Dustin Hoffman) on April 5th,
followed by four releases on April 12th: Hawaii
(1966, with Max Von Sydow, in anamorphic widescreen), Viva
Maria (1965, with Brigitte Bardot), Namu
My Best Friend (1966, with Robert Lansing), and The
Crook (1971, with Jean-Louis Trintignant. This year's set
of war releases from MGM appear on April 19th and will include Ambush
Bay (1966, with Hugh O'Brien), Attack
on the Iron Coast (1968, with Lloyd Bridges), Beach
Red (1967, with Cornel Wilde), Beachhead
(1954, with Tony Curtis), The Four
Feathers (1939, with Ralph Richardson), The
Purple Plain (1954, with Gregory Peck), The
Quiet American (1958, with Audie Murphy), and Submarine
X-1 (1968, with James Caan).
Paramount has postponed its planned February 22nd release of Have
Gun Will Travel: Season Two to an undetermined future
date. Li'l Abner (1959, with
Peter Palmer) and Darling Lili
(1970, with Julie Andrews) are set for an April 19th release. In
more general news, the company has indicated that it plans to make
more of its unreleased film and TV material available on DVD. Of
course, what exactly that might translate into for classic fans
remains to be seen. A release of 1950's The
Furies (Walter Huston's last film) would be a good start
and it sure would be nice to see the 1938 The
Buccaneer and long-promised Miracle
of Morgan's Creek (two of the very few pre-1949 sound
films that Paramount retains the rights to).
Further news from Photoplay Productions suggests that Unknown
Chaplin is going ahead as a DVD release although in what
regions and when exactly is unclear as yet. There is also a desire
by Freemantle (the successor to Thames Television) to get Hollywood
out on DVD but nothing concrete appears to have happened as yet.
Sparkhill DVD will release a two-disc set on February 1st entitled:
Ray Harryhausen: The Early Years
Collection. It will feature Harryhausen's earliest work,
including the Mother Goose Stories
(Little Miss Muffet, Old
Mother Hubbard, The Queen of
Hearts, Humpty Dumpty)
and Fairy Tales (Little
Red Riding Hood, Hansel and
Gretel, Rapunzel,
King Midas, The
Tortoise and the Hare). Also included will be very early
tests and experiments as well as a wealth of supplementary material.
Universal will release the Shirley
Temple: Little Darling Pack on April 19th. It will
include Little Miss Marker
(1934, with Adolph Menjou) and Now and
Forever (1934, with Gary Cooper and Carole Lombard). Also
in Universal's plans for 2005 is a new SE of To
Kill a Mockingbird (1962, with Gregory Peck).
On March 15th, VCI will release a couple of westerns - The
Sundowners (1950, with Robert Preston, Robert Sterling,
and Chill Wills) and High Lonesome
(1950, with John Drew Barrymore, Lois Butler, and Chill Wills
again). The John Wayne Cliffhanger
Collection (The Three
Musketeers, Hurricane Express,
and Shadow of the Eagle - all
Mascot serials from the early 1930s) is now scheduled for March
29th. The Clutch Cargo Collection
is also in the works.
As, I imagine, everyone now knows, Warner Bros.' release of Bette
Davis's The Letter (1940) did
not include the promised 1929 version as an extra. Supposedly a
legal problem prevented its inclusion at the last minute. It will
apparently be released on its own at a later date this year or next.
Other titles believed to be in the works for DVD as a result of
recent restorations are Baby Face
(1933, with Barbara Stanwyck), Two
Seconds (1932, with Edward G. Robinson), and The
Scarlet Letter (1926, with Lillian Gish). No timing is
known as yet. The marvelous King's Row
(1942, with Ann Sheridan and Ronald Reagan) is also understood to be
in the works. In May, Warners will reportedly feature Doris Day with
six releases: Billy Rose's Jumbo
(1962), The Glass Bottom Boat
(1966), Love Me or Leave Me
(1955), Lullaby of Broadway
(1951), Please Don't Eat the Daisies
(1960), and Young Man with a Horn
(1950). Which prompts me to wonder where the long promised Errol
Flynn box set is? Other Warner releases for 2005 will include the
Maverick television series and
High Definition discs of North by
Northwest (1959) and The Music
Man (1962), the latter two in the 4th quarter.
In Region 2 news, the British Film Institute will release two discs
featuring the early (1900-1913) work filmmakers Sagar Mitchell and
James Kenyon who roamed the north of England, Scotland, Ireland and
Wales, filming the everyday lives of people at work and play. The
discs are The Lost World of Mitchell and
Kenyon (due January 31st) and Electric
Victorians: The Films of Mitchell and Kenyon (spring
2005). Other 2005 releases from the BFI will include Luis Bunuel's
Tristana (1970), The
Mysterians (1957), Federico Fellini's Il
Bidone (1955), and Jacques
Tati Shorts (Soigne ton gauche
[Watch Your Left!] (1936),
L'Ecole des facteurs [School
for Postmen] (1947) and Cours
du soir [Evening Classes]
(1967)). France's MK2 will issue a companion piece to its Stan
Laurel Collection disc on April 6th. It will be called
Hardy and feature 10 of Oliver
Hardy's silent shorts. Universal will release Double
Indemnity on March 28th. Finally, a newly reconstructed
version of Eisenstein's Battleship
Potemkin (1925) is proposed for DVD in late 2005, but the
distributor is unknown at present.
Well, that's it for another column. Next time I'll be back with a
clutch of new reviews in one of the usual Classic
Reviews Roundups.
Barrie Maxwell
barriemaxwell@thedigitalbits.com |
Barrie
Maxwell - Main Page
|
|